Why Japan FEARS these GIRLS: A DANGEROUS Beauty
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I1L6W5Z13NI
无作者
Intro
Japan is known for a lot of niche subcultures. It’s the only place in the world where you can see, someone dressed up in sleek techwear with outfits so stylish you’d swear you’ve been transported to,
sleek:
(often disapproving) (of a person)
Link to original
looking rich, and dressed in elegant and expensive clothes
a sleek and ambitious politician
night city from the game Cyberpunk, standing right next to a ganguro with her tanned skin,thick make up and enough bright colors to fill a child’s coloring book. But not all Japanese, subcultures are made equal. Some of them can have very dark and downright depressing origins. And, one of these dark subcultures is called Jirai Kei. and Unlike other subcultures in Japan like gyaru,where it started out as a way of rebelling against conservative Japanese social beauty standards.Jirai kei has its origins in the infamous red light district in Japan called Kabukicho,as well as in the stigma that surrounds the topic of mental health in the country. The, primary stereotype for women in this subculture is that they’re cute and girly on the outside.
but are obsessive, emotionally unstable and self-damaging on the inside. And this, is also the primary criticism of Jirai Kei. Cus even though a lot of people in, the Jirai Kei scene are trying to fight against this stigma and use the subculture as a way to, raise awareness about mental health in Japan, there is still criticism of this subculture, for supposedly glamourising having mental health issues and self damaging tendencies.And that’s what I wanted to explore in this video. How did Jirai Kei get, started exactly? And what’s with the mental health aspect? And for, a subculture that’s all about the damages of mental illnesses, what’s with all the, lace ribbons and frills? And the answer to that is a lot more simple than you think.
If Depressed, Why Cute?
So it’s really important for me to mention that the word Jirai in Jirai Kei originated, as a derogatory term. The word is derived from the phrase “Jirai Onna” meaning “Landmine woman” which, is a term used to stereotype women who when you first meet them are outwardly very kind, and bubbly but later on turn out to be mentally unstable and with major personality issues. The, closest I can think of are like those memes by people that really want to bang hot women from, jails and psychwards, for some reason. But it’s still important to know that while the, term is a bit tongue and cheek, it was still a way to diminish women that were genuinely facing, problems with mental health. And this imagery does play a huge part in the Jirai subculture,because a lot of the fashion revolves around evoking this landmine idea. Like the classic, Jirai Kei look uses a lot of clothing that is traditionally very feminine. blouses with tons.
of lace and ruffles. Frilly high waisted skirts and chunky platform shoes. But it’s contrasted, against small details like the Jirai Line. Which is the iconic style of make up in the, jirai kei scene meant to evoke the image of someone who’se been crying by making the eyes, look more baggy and swollen. This is meant to signify that the person is “damaged” in a way,it’s meant to convey that this person is emotionally fragile and vulnerable.Even the clothing that i mentioned just now are stylised differently. Rather than, looking traditionally girl with bright pastel colors, jirai Kei fashion uses a, color palette that’s more darker in tone such as black, dark red and dark pink. Point is,Jirai Kei is all about this contrast. They look super feminine, but have small signs indicating, that they’ll absolutely crash out on you if they want to. And unlike simple teenage edginess there, is a dark reason behind these aesthetic choices. Cus you got to remember Jirai Kei has part of its.
origins in the red light district of Kabukicho. Specifically with a group called toyoko Kids, Toyoko kids are essentially Japanese runaway children. These kids come from broken homes, with abusive parents and difficult home lives, with no emotional safety. So a lot of them end, up running away to the big cities like Tokyo or Osaka. And in these big cities, with no financial, security or qualifications, a lot of them end up working in the nightlife industry in places like, Kabukicho. Places like Host clubs and cabaret bars took advantage of these runaway children,and some of these kids even took part in enjo Kosai or “underaged sugar daddying”. And while, they’re not the creators of the Jirai Kei subculture, there was overlap between them and, Jirai Kei. a lot of these toyoko kids were also wearing dark pastel coloured outfits with heavy, eyeliners and frilly chokers. So it wasn’t long before Japanese society lumped these two groups.
together. It reinforced the idea that if you see a girl in Jirai Kei, she might be an emotionally, messed up runaway, obsessed with going to host clubs and validation from random men.And while a lot of work is being done to fight this stigma or at the very least,separate the aesthetic of Jirai Kei and its dark history. There are still criticisms of, the subculture about the glamourisation of being emotionally compromised. Because, the line separating empowerment and exploitation is sometimes razor thin.
Trauma, But Make it Aesthetic
So it’s no big surprise that Japan isn’t really the best place when it comes to mental health, awareness. Not saying that other countries are, but when “death by overwork” becomes, a codified term in your society, it does beg the question. But this reluctance to, acknowledge mental health issues have motivated some people to find ways to make taboo subjects, more visible. Just like Jirai Kei, there are other subcultures that are all about mental, health awareness. Subcultures like Yami Kawaii or Menhera, aren’t just about the shock value, of openly wearing your mental struggles but also about the self expression that comes from that.And in a country where you’re encouraged to keep the doors to your emotions shut,you do get a reputation when you are open about taboo subjects such as these.For example, in a newsletter by the faculty of Foreign Studies in Nagoya University,they ran a survey asking students if they would approach a person dressed.
up in Jirai Kei fashion which 67% of respondents said that they would not citing reasons such as, “I associate Jirai-Kei with people who are a little sick or menhera. This makes me nervous, Which side tangent - Menhera is a real slang term in Japan used to describe someone that is facing mental health issues, But Menhera has its also fashion subculture that’s also about advocating for mental health awareness, honestly there is a lot of overlap between menhera and Jirai Kei since they’re kinda considered sister subcultures in a way. So yeah that’s just some added context I couldn’t fit into the script, anyway back to the video.to talk to them–their personalities seem cold or distant.” as well as “‘I imagine Jiraikei people, as being surrounded by a dark atmosphere. They seem scary when I talk to them.’”, And while a large part of this reputation is definitely due to misunderstanding the subculture, and the intentions behind the people in it, some of it also comes from the criticism that the.
subculture has faced, namely the fetishization of having mental health issues as well as the, glorification of things like drug use and Sex work. For example, since the subculture is rooted, in taboo subjects like mental illness and self harm, there are those that criticize Jirai Kei, for making these things look quirky and cute due to how Jirai Kei fashion inherently looks,which in turns ignores the unpleasant parts of living with chronic mental health issues. And, while plenty of people in the subculture are okay with you interacting with just the fashion aspect, of it, there is a constant back and forth between the struggle of letting people do what they want, and the inherent problem of romanticizing a lifestyle that is very difficult. It also has, to be mentioned that fetishizing anything in general has its own set of problems,due to the stereotypes that come when people see you as weak or incapable or.
in a specific way. It is a slippery slope at the end of the day when you’re talking about, mental health and I feel the last thing anyone would want is for others to have preconceived, notions on who you are Yokogaomag said it the best in their article about Jirai Kei, with, “Although it is self-evident that not everyone adhering to the style struggles with severe mental, health issues…This prejudice impacts all Jirai Kei enthusiasts with equal force. To this day, it, shows no restraint and is rigidly applied to all individuals who identify with this fashion style.”, There’s also the criticism that Jirai Kei indirectly encourages hyper consumerism due, to the fashion being very specific in style, with some elitists in the subculture looking, down on you if you don’t get specific named brand items that you can only find in Japan.Which makes things 10x more expensive if you live anywhere other than Japan. But, honestly as someone who lives in Malaysia and is into the plastic crack that is 40K,
I shouldn’t be the one to moralise about something being too expensive to consume.My little plastic men demand a lot from me and one of those things is my wallet.And that’s the fragile balance that Jirai Kei currently sits between. For some it’s, a way to express what it’s like to live with illnesses that don’t necessarily have cures,for others it’s a stereotype to be avoided. But even with all this stigma,Jirai Kei is more popular than ever. And the crazy thing is, even before watching this video,you’ve probably seen Jirai Kei before without even knowing it.
Sad Girls Make Great Content
So the crazy thing about researching for this video was finding just how much media, there was involving Jirai Kei that I didn’t know existed. Like i’m not just talking about anime,manga and light novels adaptations but also straight up appearing in video games. Like, yeah you have your gimmicky light novels, where the entire schtick is that you can romantically, pursue a Jirai Kei girl but then you get to popular titles like Needy Streamer Overload, which deals with the real nitty gritty of the Jirai Kei Scene. The game is all about, managing the main character Ame’s online career as she wants to become a top tier streamer. So, you get to help with things like replying to fans, researching topics for future streams,and according to the steam page “squeeze stupid amounts of Super Chat out of her donation-happy, otaku followers.” which is totally not reflective of the modern day streaming landscape.And the thing is, the game also nails the portrayal of Jirai Kei not just fashion wise,
with ame being dressed up in that iconic Jirai Kei style,but also in personality. Here’s how the game ‘s steam page describes ame,“ While she may look somewhat low-key and quiet,she’s actually a ridiculously selfish and vapid girl with a tendency to get carried, away and a desperate need for approval. She’s, well… kind of troublesome personality. “, And you do actually have to help Ame with her troublesome personality. Part of the game is, also about helping ame regulate her mental state off stream by deciding what kind of vices to give,how intimate or cordial you the player want to be with her and manage how she interacts with, toxic fans. And depending on how far or how lax your choices have been, it can result in, very dark endings for Ame. And while I’ve yet to play the game, from reviews that I found both on, steam and reddit, a lot of people actually do praise the game for its tasteful portrayal of.
living with mental illnesses and chronic addiction and showing that these kinds of people probably, shouldn’t be given unregulated internet access. And that’s actually a huge running theme in a, lot of media that portray Jirai kei. The idea that getting better isn’t really that easy when, you’re in a self perpetuating cycle.that yeah we are responsible for our actions, but the, environments that we’re in absolutely play a part in encouraging the best and worst parts of us.And another place you can see this is in the manga series called “Tomorrow,I’ll Be Someone’s Girlfriend’. It’s an anthology manga series that focuses on the more realistic, side of industries like host clubs and rental girlfriends. Where other certain, anime and manga might show rental girlfriends as this lighthearted and almost inspiring tale,here it shows that most often than naught, the people in it do it out of desperation more than.
anything else. With imbalance being inherent in a lot of these industries. And one of the, characters, Yua, does go through this. She’s a runaway kid that goes to Shinjuku with no plan, whatsoever once she gets there. And throughout her parts of the story, you basically see her, spiral as she slowly gets taken advantage of by the seedy people and places in and, around Shinjuku. Ultimately falling prey to the superficial attention that places like host clubs, provide. And throughout the story as well you do see her repping that standard Jirai Kei look,which ties back to that idea in the subculture of the unstable landmine personality.And while yua and ame are fictional characters, the stories that they’re meant to embody are, ones that happen all the time in places like Kabukicho. Emotionally compromised people being, dragged further down by the circumstances of their environment desperately seeking a place to belong.
But what’s important to remember is that Jirai Kei isn’t just a tragic trope, or a label for the, unstable girls. The subculture is and has always been about taking ownerships of the things that, can hurt you. Maybe it was something traumatic, maybe it’s something that you still live with,maybe it’s something you can’t help but have. The subculture is all about living with what hurts you, and moving forward despite that. And yeah it gets criticized, but honestly what subculture doesn’t.You have so many examples of previous subculture movements being misunderstood for the longest of, times before they were accepted. But for the people who find meaning in Jirai Kei. It’s a, reminder that being damaged doesn’t mean you can’t be seen. That at the end of the day, with however, long it takes, you will find a way past your pain, and in doing so, take ownership of it.