Tyla: Beautiful But Boring
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QCnUXlhcLWo&t=75s
无作者
When you surf the internet,and if you scroll through TikTok and Reddit long enough,[clears throat] you’ll notice a very specific aggressive, critique popping up about [music] Tyla.She’s undeniably gorgeous, but she has zero personality.And she’s arrogant, she’s an industry plant,a diva, she’s flopping,and the only thing keeping her [music] relevant in the industry, is her pretty privilege.These are some of the harshest labels [music] an artist or musician, can get internet and in the entertainment industry today.But, why are millions of people convinced that behind the viral dance moves,Met Gala looks, and flawless face,there’s no actual substance, [music] just corporate PR and an attitude?
PR
the abbreviation for public relations 公关,公共关系(全写为 public relations)
a PR department/agency/campaign
公关部门/机构/活动
The article is very good PR for the theatre.
这篇文章有助于加强该剧院的公共关系。
So, is Tyla genuinely out of touch and boring,or is she just sweet and authentic [music] and deeply misunderstood, by the public?And today,we’re going to be breaking down [music] the internet’s obsession, with calling Tyla pretty with no personality,[music] and whether if she’s actually arrogant.
or if the internet just hates beautiful women.[music] >> Oh my god.>> [music] >> Hello, my lovers,and welcome back to another episode.So, long story short,for about 5 years now, I’ve just had a repetitive dream of natural disasters,but most of it is just floods and tsunami, and I’m always frantic,looking for my family, looking for my mother,my brother, yelling out,trying to help people.You can take that a few ways.You can take that as a bad dream, you can take that as my psychological stage,maybe I’m emotional because apparently in psychology and dreams,water resembles emotions, or you can say that I’m quite a psychic.Is the world experiencing, [music] just on a global scale,experiencing more floods recently, especially in 2026.And [music] yes,the world is experiencing more frequent and intense, severe floods and extreme rainfall events,driven by a combination of human-induced, climate change and a strong El Niño pattern.I’ve also made a video a few years ago, actually,
when no one watched me.Basically, I just said what I said now.[music] I had dreams and flashbacks of rain, of floods,of natural disasters happening.And right now, it’s happening.America, I think it was California 2 3 days ago,experienced flooding.There’s more flooding now.The weather, the climate’s crazy right now in Australia,Sydney, Australia.People are on edge.Something’s coming.People think that [music] we’re going to experience like another huge, global flood,like Noah’s Ark.A lot of Christians are saying, in the Bible Jesus mentioned, moving to the mountains, when the world is coming to an end because apparently, it’s safer there.I don’t know.Okay, I don’t know,but I do feel like the world is ending.I don’t mean to be dramatic.I hate fearmongering.There’s something that’s so spiritual about it.Those who get it just get it.If you don’t get it, then just take it with a grain of salt.And you might actually think I’m going through a psychosis, but I’m not.
I actually feel more sane than ever speaking this out loud.I’ve come to terms with most things in my life.Like if I go, I go.You know what I mean?I don’t really care.Do what you can to help the climate, the environment,you know, don’t litter,don’t over-consume, don’t over-buy.Just leave Mother Nature and let her sleep and heal a little bit, shall we?Shall we just do that for Mother Nature?So, that’s what’s going on around the world today.>> [music] >> Bit of reality check,some real news before we dive into some less important stuff.Not saying Tyla is not important, but just >> Hey,Mr.nonchalance.I like your eyes cuz it’s matched my tone.>> So, who is Tyla?Tyla is a South African singer and songwriter who rose to international, fame with her hit Water.On a piano and Afrobeat’s influences,she has become one of the most recognizable, young artists to emerge from South Africa in recent years.[music] Her music, dance trends,and distinctive style has helped her build a huge audience.
Tyla has helped bring South African music to a wider audience.Tyla was born in January 2002, making her 24 years old.She’s like 1 year older than my brother.Crap.When you look at it that way, she’s actually very young.She’s like so young.And like, I’m 28.I’m not that much older than her,but like I look at my little brother like an actual baby.Like my little brother’s 23, and I look at him like he’s still like Hi.She was born in Johannesburg, South Africa.Her breakthrough hit Water has become a global sensation in 2023, and earn her the inaugural, Grammy Award for Best African Music Performance in 2024.I actually spoke to my housemate about this topic as I was researching.She has great judgment and discernment.I just wanted to hear what she said.And like, we both watched Tyla’s interviews together.We watched a lot.Quenlin Blackwell.She’s so freaking funny and just charismatic, beautiful,open, great personality.I really like her as a personality, as internet personality,as a YouTuber.
I think she was born to do YouTube.Housemate and I just watched a lot of Tyla’s videos getting a sense of her,how she bounces off other people’s energy.Because you know how some people can be different around certain people.They could be like a little more soft-spoken, around certain people and more open and bubbly around other people.So, we gave Tyla a chance,okay?We gave Tyla a chance.We really sat down and was patient.And look, I’m not going to lie.She’s kind of like very one-dimensional in all these interviews.It It She’s just being herself.Is she serving face?100% body tea?1,000% Her eyes sparkle, she’s got a amazing smile,she’s polite.I don’t see arrogance,maybe in like one or two clips that got the public a little triggered,which we will talk about.I think it’s got some things to do with the award show and also Rihanna.But is she lacking an aura and that pop star essence?Yeah, I I think so,but then again,it’s like maybe people expect.
her to have it because she is a woman of color in the pop industry.Maybe people expect her to have a certain persona, or a certain essence or vibe and Tyla’s just being herself.I do really think that she’s just being herself.This is just who Tyla is,which sparked a lot of speculations, that she could be a industry, plant because she lacks a lot of aura and personality.But then again,I do want to emphasize having a personality, doesn’t just mean you’re extroverted and outgoing.of times when someone’s a little bit more introverted and on the shy side,more soft-spoken, more gentle,more quiet,a lot of people will assume that that person just doesn’t have personality.That person just lacks aura.But I think that’s just not true.I think being introverted or quiet and prefers more neutral, and peaceful interactions,perhaps more reserved, it doesn’t mean that they don’t have a personality.That is their personality.That is a personality.But I can understand where the public is coming from.
She just gets straight to the point if asked a question.She doesn’t joke much about it,which is why some people say that she seems boring or low energy.In December 2024,a video of Tyla performing South Africa, prompted, criticism, from some local viewers who felt, she looked tired or lacked the, energy they expected.Some commenters questioned why she appeared more energetic at international, performances,while others defended her, pointing to the demands of frequent travel,recording, rehearsals,and promotional appearances.This is one of the clearest examples behind the boring criticism.Although it is primarily, a debate [music] about performance rather than substantiated, personal controversy.So here are some reoccurring perceptions, and why people find her on the more boring side.Her facial expressions,when she appears reserved or maintains a relatively neutral expression,some viewers interpret it as boredom or lack of enthusiasm.Many viewers judge her on her interview style and expect outspoken funny,
charismatic,or highly expressive celebrity interviews may find her quieter, manner less engaging.Her stage energy,clips from individual performances, can circulate without the context of full show,making a tired or subdued moment seem representative, of [music] her entire career.Her glamorous styling and confident image can lead some people to expect, a bigger personality, than [music] they see in interviews.Emily Ratajkowski, I’m sorry if I butchered that last name,but Emily is like another beautiful, gorgeous woman.She’s also more reserved.She doesn’t talk much.I would put her in that category.Also Jennie from Blackpink who dance, who sings,but a lot of viewers, a lot of fans think that Jennie’s boring,lacks energy, but maybe Jennie not maybe,but Jennie’s definitely just tired from more than a decade of just performing, and being a K-pop star,doing gigs after gigs, shows after shows,interviews after interviews.I mean, it requires a lot of energy to be famous,be a celebrity.
So I think I would put Tyla in that category.I don’t think she’s malicious or evil or ungrateful.And like I said,I was talking to my housemate, about this and she brought up a great point that you know,she’s just young, kids,the people, people on her PR team,maybe a lot of mentors being in her ear telling her how to act.Perhaps this is her way of being like, well,this is me.Like accept it or not, this is just me.I’m just this type of person.I don’t want to be the outspoken, bubbly,charismatic R&B or pop star.It reminds me of Jennie, but then again,Jennie is a K-pop star and she was shaped, you know,she was shaped to be in the industry.She was trained to be in the industry and I think Tyla is somewhat that as well.I don’t think she’s just someone that came on set and was 100% ready.You put her in, you put her interviews and she’s ready to go.She doesn’t need media training.The X factor, you know,the natural stardom persona, the charisma,she doesn’t have that.
I think she was seen as someone with a lot of potential, and the industry really tried to help her and build her personality,but I don’t think you can teach charisma.I don’t think you can teach having the the X factor spark.It doesn’t exist in everyone.Someone that knows how to work the crowd,knows how to engage with every single person in an interview.I just don’t think she has that and that’s okay.Which is why I think the speculation that she’s an industry plant,I think that’s how it came in.At face value, superficially,a beautiful star,someone that could be made into a star and she got picked for her potential, because she’s talented and a bit of encouragement,a bit of training, she could really become something.All of this can coexist and that doesn’t necessarily mean that she’s 100%, an industry plant.It’s kind of the same as K-pop as well.A lot of K-pop stars that we see now were once upon a time, someone with a lot of passion and potential, and they were trained to become K-pop stars.
That could also be Tyla.Not saying that’s 100% the case, but that could be one of the cases.Here are some main reasons why people make the accusation, and is calling Tyla an industry plant.[music] Her rise to fame seemed almost overnight.Tyla seemed to appear out of nowhere when Water exploded on TikTok in 2023.Within a relatively short period, she was receiving major award nominations,international press coverage, and opportunities alongside established stars.This made some people suspicious that her success has been planned in advance,rather than driven primarily by public demand.South African publication IOL noted that her rapid rise, particularly in the US,contributed to the industry plant accusations.She also had major backing behind her breakthrough.Tyla signed with Epic Records, a subsidiary of Sony Music,in 2021 before Water became a global hit.Her team included established managers, producers,and label executives who helped her develop her music and international career.
In 2024,Music Week interviewed, Epic executives, to describe the deliberate work that went into developing her sound.Her team recorded several singles before Water,and they recognized the song’s potential to connect with streaming audiences, and radio listeners.That is evidence of a planned marketing and artist [music] development strategy.People also question how much of her image is manufactured.[music], Another reason for the accusation, is how neatly Tyla’s image fits the modern global pop market.Polished visuals, memorable choreography,fashion partnership,and a sound that blends South African amapiano with pop and R&B.Some critics interpret this as a carefully constructed, product designed to appeal, to international, audiences.[music] Her team has openly discussed, wanting to bring African music to global audience.Tyla herself said that she wants to be an African pop star,rather than simply another singer,and has emphasized her involvement in her music and visuals.
A lot of critics have also thought that Water, the song,was engineered to go viral because the song had a catchy hook,danceable amapiano rhythm,and a recognizable dance challenge that made it particularly suited to TikTok.I think whether or not she is an industry plant or not,a lot of countries are starting to kind of imitate, what Korea is doing with the K-pop stardom success.I don’t really like the entertainment industry full stop.They work for the elites.They are made to influence, brainwash the public,especially the people that have no idea what’s going on.They’re there to generate money, obviously generate self-power,influence, but there are also great movies and music out there,the good quality ones, but I just mean the more mainstream stuff.I don’t support most of the things that goes on in the entertainment industry.You don’t have to consume, you don’t have to be a part of the conversation,you don’t have to get triggered, you don’t have to involve yourself in it.
But if you do like it, there’s also no shame in that.If you see it for what it is, if you can be honest about it,if you can be aware.And also being an industry plant or not, it doesn’t matter.The goal is to make money.Whether someone’s charismatic, and is not an industry plant or they’re manufactured pop stars or celebrities,it kind of doesn’t really matter at the end of the day because the goal is to, make the public obsessed and to make money.It’s all about money.So, I don’t really care in that aspect.I think I care more about what do famous people or celebrities, or people with great power do with their power and influence.Do they help the people more?Do they support humanity?Do they support people in need?Do they make the world a better place?What do they do with their power?Are they genuine?Are they kind-hearted?Are they generous?I like that.Obviously, you don’t have to be,but I respect, and love a celebrity or someone with more power and influence more when they do.
So, that’s I guess what I look at.Are they a generous,pure-hearted, person that genuinely wants the world a better place, or they just kind of want fame for the sake of fame and they just love money,power, and influence and they don’t really care about anything else.I think that’s the distinction for me whenever someone becomes incredibly, global and famous.So, I wanted to get into why do people find Tyla arrogant?The trophy incident,critics interpreted her request for help holding her NVA trophy as entitled.Tyla explained that the trophy was heavy and she wanted to concentrate, on her speech.One of the hosts, was handing over a card, and she also didn’t take it, and I think there was also a thing where she patted her assistant, on the back and people thought, like I don’t know.People just thought she lacked awareness, seemed to be in her own world.It was diva behavior.She could have handled that a little better.It’s little moments like that.Like I get it.I watched it and like was I annoyed?
A little bit.But then I thought like what has this got to do with me?You can say she’s 24 and she’s very young for the industry,but 24 is also not that young to understand, just basic etiquette and having awareness.But then again, everyone’s different and everyone’s on their own timeline.It was giving like I’m so petite.Like I’m petite.I’m skinny.I’m I’m that girl.Like it’s too heavy for me.It was giving a little bit of that.It’s not like we don’t like Tyla.It could be anyone really.It’s the lack of awareness that can be a little bit off-putting.My mother [music] is super thin.My mother’s thinner than Tyla.My mom’s just a thin, short, Asian woman and she can lift like five bricks, by herself when she’s doing gardening.If my mom can do that at the age of 50, I’m sure a 24-year-old pop star,she seems very healthy, very fit as well.I’m sure she has no problems holding a trophy.The second moment was the avoiding the identity question.Her silence during the Breakfast Club interview was interpreted.
by some viewers as invasive.Others felt she shouldn’t have been pressured to explain a complicated, personal identity on the spot.Others thought her silence was arrogance and avoidance.Moment number three, her blunt responses online.Her response to Britney Spears outfit comparison, showed that she is willing to confront people directly.Some see that as confidence, others see it as disrespectful.I don’t know.Sometimes you just can’t please everyone.When I stay silent sometimes to some hate comments,I’m seen as like [music] ignorant or avoidant.If I do reply, then people will say,“Well, be the bigger person.You don’t have to respond to it.” And things like that, you can just never win.I think defending yourself is always okay.We should defend ourselves, but you pick your battles.You get what I’m saying?And then there are other times where staying silent is just the smartest move.Sometimes saying nothing at all, we should all learn a little of that.
We should all know when to keep our mouths shut.So,I don’t personally have a problem when someone chooses not to say anything, or when someone chooses to defend themselves.It’s when people get catty and abusive and violent and aggressive,like have really bad attitudes or entitled diva behavior, that’s when I’m like,“Ooh,I’m going to stay away from that.” But when people are defending, themselves or choosing to stay silent, and not wanting to answer a question or not wanting to participate in something,that’s fine.You pick your battles.You really do.Another thing that pissed a lot of people off was the controversy with Rihanna.The tension between the two fan bases stems from music style comparisons, and a specific viral event at the Met Gala.The Met Gala snub rumor.Social media erupted after a viral moment showed an awkward interaction, between Tyla and Rihanna.Tyla approached Rihanna to say hello,but the encounter ended abruptly, when Rihanna politely excused herself stating her baby daddy,
A$AP Rocky, was calling her and walked away.And this was the internet’s reaction.Some internet users accused Rihanna of being dismissive, or hating on the newer artist.Conversely,critics accused Tyla of trying to expose Rihanna or use the awkward interaction, for clout when she later posted a TikTok discussing how uncomfortable, and awkward the moment felt.[music] Industry figures like Jason Lee on Page Six Radio defended, Rihanna saying people overanalyzed, a normal busy moment.Tyla quickly shut down rumors stating everyone knows I love Ri, and explained she felt awkward because Rihanna looked busy.Honestly, it could be both of their PR teams being like Guys,do this so we can get clout and get the public talking.You know what I mean?It’s like it happens on a daily basis with normal humans.You get busy, you get ignored sometimes,you get pushed to the side.It happens to the best of us.You get over it, you move on.I don’t think that Tyla thinks that she’s better than Rihanna.
I don’t think Rihanna’s like hating on Tyla and being dismissive on purpose.She just looked kind of over it.Like Rihanna overall now, she just looks over it.She’s just like get me home.I just want to lay down and retire.But then there are discussions, about the replica and the bigger than the program debates.Music critics and fans frequently, compare Tyla’s music style and, visual aesthetics, to Rihanna’s, early career.This was compounded, by an old interview clip with Trevor Noah where Tyla confidently, stated she would one day be bigger than Rihanna.>> I look up to Rihanna.She’s done an amazing job,and I hope to one day be on that level and even bigger.>> While her fans saw it as healthy ambition,Rihanna’s fans found it disrespectful.More recently,Tyla faced backlash when her official account reposted a review comparing, her to Rihanna,forcing Tyla to post an Instagram, story telling critics y’all dragging, it and implying her team or account, was compromised.I don’t know.
This is when I think the immaturity and the lack of self-awareness comes in.I don’t think Tyla thinks that she’s better than Rihanna.I think it sounded like yeah, you know what?I want to be bigger than Rihanna, not Rihanna itself,maybe what Rihanna represents.Like I want to be the biggest thing, the biggest new star,which is what you would expect from someone very amateur and lacks PR training.Someone like that would say.It’s kind of harmless.It’s innocuous.It’s innocent.A lot of teenage girls I know would say something like that.I probably would have said something like that when I was a teenager.I don’t think it’s malicious, but I think it yeah,it’s a little bit annoying and a little bit ignorant.You could have said it in different ways.Like, I want to be the most recognized or,you know, I’m the world’s going to know my name.You know, something like that.But,saying, that you’re going to be bigger than a specific, person and not expect their fans to come for you.
Again, I just think this girl is very fresh to the industry.She’s got a lot of ambition.And ambition without self-awareness, without modesty can become arrogant.It can become self-entitlement.And that’s not to say the world hates confident people.It comes to a point where you need to be wise, and have wisdom and know that confidence can easily become arrogance, if unchecked.And that’s going to harm the person that’s going through it.Some critics can be violent and aggressive and attack Tyla,but the people that can see it would be more caring and understanding, towards her.They can see things a little bit deeper.But, I don’t think the internet hates beautiful women.I think both sides are misunderstood.I think a lot of people see things clearly,but they don’t have the emotional maturity, or the depth [music] to vocalize or communicate how they truly feel.So, it comes across as hate,but I don’t know.Clean communication, clarity,emotional control,seeing things.
on a deeper level can probably help us communicate what we’re thinking, out loud more clearly without aggression.So, that’s what I want to say.I think I get why the critics are mad.I completely understand.And I get why people say that she thinks she’s above the program.She’s trying to be Rihanna.There’s also accusations that she wants to be Britney Spears.She’s dressing like every single person but herself.I can completely understand that,but I also think it’s a massive misunderstanding.And we do need to bring, complexity and nuances into these types of conversations,so we don’t think [music] black and white.We don’t put anyone on a pedestal.And we also don’t idolize anyone.And also, we don’t dethrone anyone either.Because no one is 100% good and evil.And no one is 100% black and white either.And I think seeing things with clarity, and having more depth and understanding the complexity, can also help us enjoy these types of things better.
We’re able to enjoy it without feeling overly emotional or personally attacked.These are some of the negative things that people do say about Tyla.Perceptions of her attitude.Some corners of the internet label Tyla as unlikable,claiming she exhibits a sense of entitlement and behaves like an industry plant.Body shaming.Following high-profile appearances,Tyla has also been subjected to harsh, social media scrutiny regarding her physical, appearance with trolls picking apart her figure, and claiming she had gained weight.[music] This sparked significant, counter backlash from her fan base, and fellow artists like SZA who publicly, stepped in to defend Tyla against the internet’s unrealistic, [music] body standards.If drama, just drama in general,if the entertainment industry, if all these uh online speculations and stuff,if it triggers you so much that you get emotional, and you have to go online to attack, people and have a fight with, people across the world where, you don’t even know about a star.
that doesn’t even know your existence.Obviously, I don’t blame you 100% for that.I think the entertainment the entertainment industry and you know,the tech industry, we’re given the platform to do so,right?And we’re also kind of all influenced, and exploited by the entertainment industry as well.They want to sell it to us, the audience,the consumers.So, it’s not 100% these people’s fault.And mind you, some of these audiences,a lot of the audiences are children.They’re like underage girls most most of the time, very emotional.But, I do want to say,and I say this with caution and care,if it bothers you that much to the point where you are lost in it,you should probably start looking deeper into that.You should probably start therapy to some degree.You should probably develop some self self-awareness and discipline, too.Seeing people get so heated up and fighting and killing each other over, politicians, or over which celebrity they like,it’s crazy because it hurts yourself and it hurts others.
And when you hurt others, you also automatically hurt yourself.You can say I don’t care all you like, but that’s not the truth.That’s not how the human spirit and human brain works.I do want to also emphasize that we are all living for the first time.It’s not like Taylor’s lived three lives.She’s new in the industry.She’s experiencing life for the first time.So is everyone else.You and I, we’re all living and learning what it’s like to be a human,learning how to be a good person, learning how to become a better person,learning how to live life, how to handle it,how to go through the chaos, how to find joy in all of this,how to survive, how to live.We are all experiencing everything for the first time and nothing is 100% black, and white.And I think remembering that can really,really help us develop a sense of awareness,a deeper understanding of the world and others, and can give us some emotional peace as well.It can ground us emotionally.Love and peace.
Thank you guys so much for watching this episode.If you made it until the end, >> [music] >> make sure you like,comment, subscribe.Always drop down in the comment, section below on what type of, videos you want to see in the, future.And [music] um until the next video, stay cool,stay healthy, stay peaceful,and I’ll see you guys next week in next week’s video.[music] Ciao.