00:00:00 - 00:00:51
Plastic surgery has been normalized in China. 20 years ago, willingly going under the [music] knife was as terrifying a thought as the phrase suggests.

under the ˈknife
(informal) having a medical operation

After all, why would anyone want to get their face sliced, pay a huge sum of money, and possibly become botched just to look better? Well, China’s cosmetic surgery market is expanding six times faster than the global average. So, today we are doing a deep dive [music] into China. It’s one of the largest markets for plastic surgery in the world, and it’s

00:00:25 - 00:01:19
fascinating because just 70 years ago, makeup and [music] any pursuit of beauty was banned in Mao’s China. So, what has caused such a drastic shift? [music] And why do more and more people, especially women, now find it worth it to go under the knife? To begin to understand their thinking, we must start first from [music] 1930s Shanghai, one of the first cities where plastic surgery was adopted in China. Plastic surgery was introduced to China from the West during the late Qing Dynasty in the 19th century. [music]

00:00:54 - 00:01:44
Though the practice, along with Western medicine, was not adopted by the Chinese straight away. When the Manchu Empire fell into crisis, spurred by military defeats and the First Opium War, Chinese intellectuals made the decision to adopt Western medicine and technology as part of the Self-Strengthening Movement. The Qing Empire ultimately fell with the Xinhai Revolution in 1911, [music] ending some long-time oppressive beauty traditions for women like feet binding, which was a practice where women

00:01:19 - 00:02:13
basically crippled themselves to achieve tiny [music] lotus-like feet. Other restrictive beauty ideals like chest binding was also no longer pursued, and ideals like gender equality were brought forward by the Xinhai Revolution. Women found themselves in a more free time. [music] They were no longer bound literally and figuratively to constrained gender roles and crippling beauty ideals. And this, gender equality, and the end of restrictive beauty ideals is what Dr. Zhang Dishan said allowed for plastic surgery to

00:01:46 - 00:02:43
really gain traction in early China. All this allowed for the first plastic surgery clinics to appear in China in the 1930s. You might be surprised to hear this, but popular procedures a century ago requested by Chinese women, already included double eyelid surgery, rhinoplasty, and breast augmentation. Very similar demands to what we see today, which is interesting because traditionally Chinese ideals of beauty involved women with monolidded almond eyes and smaller [music] breasts. So, clearly, sometime around the 1930s,

00:02:15 - 00:03:05
Chinese ideals of beauty had changed, and much of this is due to Western influence. [music] By the 1930s, Shanghai, one of the main port cities of China, was overflowing with Western imports. Western goods, films, and fashion lined the streets, which meant inevitably Western aesthetics would [music] come to influence Chinese perceptions of beauty. It’s super fascinating because we can actually see this change occur through Yuefen Pai or [music] calendar posters. This was a popular way for big brands to promote

00:02:40 - 00:03:35
their products to customers in Shanghai, and Yuefen Pai illustrations often featured attractive women alongside the products, which makes it very convenient for us to trace how beauty ideals evolved. Zheng Yibing, in their analysis of Yuefen Pai portrayals, compares the two works of two prominent artists. [music] Zhou Manhua’s illustrations in the 1920s looked like this. Women wore modest clothing, had a neutral expression, and small breasts. The women portrayed by Zheng also have very short hair. This

00:03:07 - 00:03:59
was a sign of the modern woman, a departure from traditional practices of women keeping their hair long and having them in braids, and symbolic of the changes in China’s social political climate. Now, take a look at this Yuefen Pai art in the 1930s, drawn by another prominent artist, Hu Tieying. We can immediately see some differences. The woman in Hu’s work has a curvy figure, and it’s emphasized by the sheer form-fitting dress she’s wearing and her expressive pose. Hu also depicts a woman

00:03:33 - 00:04:25
with double eyelids, whereas Zheng featured women with monolids. Chinese beauty ideals were changing, as we would expect from a country that went from imperialist to republican, from isolationist to being open for trade. Yet, more change was coming, this time even bigger than the last. [music] Two decades later, in 1949, under Chairman Mao’s rule, the pursuit of beauty was banned as opposed the frugal lifestyle that was being promoted. Actions like applying makeup was already condemned as a sign of the bourgeoisie. So, don’t

00:03:59 - 00:04:47
even think about plastic surgery. The beauty industry was shut down and would remain a non-factor for several decades until the Cultural Revolution in the 1980s. I feel like I’m dumping a lot of history on you guys, but it’s necessary. And here comes the main point. In the 1980s, the plastic surgery industry was revived under Deng Xiaoping’s policies of modernization and economic reform, which >> [music] >> aimed to spur China’s development of science and technology. The government

00:04:23 - 00:05:13
also loosened their control on how people looked, which resulted in the fashion and beauty industry having a huge comeback. The booming growth of these industries was in line with the new political objective of the state as [music] it stimulated massive growth for the economy. This is important. The growth of China’s beauty industry was now aligned with the Chinese government’s economic objectives. So, there was no reason to stop people from chasing beauty. Further, there’s a political agenda here, too. A population

00:04:48 - 00:05:40
that could afford to pursue beauty reflecting modernization, increased wealth of the people, and was a symbol [music] of China’s transformation to the world. With little political intervention and plenty of economic freedom, China welcomed a new era of beauty. Fashion magazines were the main gateway allowing consumers to keep up with the latest beauty and fashion trends, and Chinese consumers were eager to catch up on everything they had missed. When Vogue launched in China in 2005, the first run sold out in 5 days,

00:05:14 - 00:06:06
and the Chinese market quickly became Vogue’s second largest market after the US. And as demand grew for goods related to beauty, so did interest for plastic surgery. China today is one of the biggest markets in the world for plastic surgery, and the popularity of surgical procedures there is intricately tied to China’s changing landscape. All the historical context we went through just then has set us up really nicely to now dissect the motives behind the two main types of surgery consumers [music] in

00:05:40 - 00:06:32
China. One side wants surgery to look better, and the other, for reasons we will explore, feels [music] like they need plastic surgery. These motives may seem very opposed to each other, but what you’ll soon see is that these two camps are not as different as they might [music] seem. In fact, I would say they’re two sides of the same coin. >> [music] >> Many people explain the decision to get plastic surgery as a choice they’re making for [music] themselves. I don’t doubt this, and they also don’t owe us

00:06:07 - 00:06:53
any sort of explanation. But I did think of an interesting hypothetical situation related to this response. [music] Let’s say you have the choice to undergo plastic surgery, but if you did, no one other than yourself [music] would be able to see the changes you’ve made. If this was the case, would you still spend money on the surgery, endure the [music] pain, and take those risks just for you to see your new face whilst everyone else would still see your [music] past self? I’m sure some people would still

00:06:30 - 00:07:17
say yes and go through with it. However, there would also be people who pause and reconsider their decision. And let me ask you this, too. Would you rather be seen as someone who has really low security, an easy target for scammers where you might as well be holding a hack me, please sign in fluoro above your head, or be someone who’s proactive about protecting their online data and has peace of mind knowing they’re protected with Proton Pass? Wow, I’m really good at asking hard questions,

00:06:54 - 00:07:33
aren’t I? Proton Pass is a password manager, and if you don’t have one right now, you really should be getting into it. Because so much of our important information is online. Think about your bank account, your personal details that stored on various websites, your chat logs from your social medias. You don’t want to risk getting hacked and having all this information at the mercy of malicious strangers. It’s a huge headache, and it’s scary as. I’ve gotten hacked before because I didn’t have the

00:07:14 - 00:07:57
best passwords, and my friend literally 2 days ago told me he got hacked, too. He had to change all his logins, and even then, you’ll still forget about a few logins you have until it’s too late. Like how he totally forgot about his Uber Eats account until two $100 orders were made under his name. But this doesn’t have to be you because Proton Pass auto generates insanely strong passwords for you and securely stores them. It’s super easy to set up an account. I actually forgot how seamless

00:07:35 - 00:08:20
it was, so I created a new one just then to test it out. All you need is an existing email and a password, and that’s it. You’re ready to go. It took like 10 seconds if even that. Once you have an account, you won’t have to ever stress about creating strong passwords because Proton creates it for you, which means you can finally retire old passwords like bunny bunny 1 2 3. Very secure, I know. Also, get ready to be shocked. Proton Pass is free. Well, their free version is insanely cracked.

00:07:58 - 00:08:43
I don’t know how they’re making money, but they’re based in Switzerland, so maybe Swiss money just hits different. Proton Pass is an absolute game-changer for being secure online without the stress. I’d highly recommend downloading it. My friend actually got Proton after he got hacked, and he loves it. The one problem I have with him is he didn’t use my referral. Truly, it’s always your friends who let you down. But honestly, as long as you guys try Proton, I’m happy because I genuinely back them and

00:08:20 - 00:09:08
their commitment to privacy. So, definitely do check them out. Link in bio or not, sign up however you want. It only takes 10 seconds to sign up. It’s literally free, and you’ll be saving yourself hours and hours of time and mental load in the future. Thank you, Proton Pass, for sponsoring this video. And now, going back to the topic of plastic surgery and societal expectations. While plastic surgery may help individuals see themselves in [music] a better light, part of their expectations is often founded upon how

00:08:44 - 00:09:31
society perceives [music] them. And that’s where we have to consider the bigger picture, China’s macro environment, which will explain situations like parents gifting their daughters double eyelid surgery when they graduate. [music] To deconstruct this, I’ll have to introduce you to the concept of beauty capital. But first, what is capital? There are a couple different forms as identified by Pierre Bourdieu [music] in 1986, and I’ll go through a few of them. Economic capital, for example, are all

00:09:07 - 00:09:55
the assets and resources one owns that can be converted [music] into money. Social capital are the networks and relationships we have and they often reflect our [music] social position or status. Cultural capital refers to our knowledge, skills, and education, achievements that are recognized by society and [music] seen as prestigious. Bourdieu didn’t come up with the concept of beauty capital, but you can see how beauty can be leveraged as capital, opening up valuable opportunities and allowing one to move upwards [music] in

00:09:31 - 00:10:19
society. Beauty as a form of capital becomes very apparent when you’re in a culture that highly values outward appearances. [music] And when it comes to China, one reason why looks or beauty can become an advantage is because of its fiercely [music] competitive environment. I mentioned before the practice of gifting double eyelid surgery. This is done at a time when competition is often at its most fierce. Millions of graduates enter the workforce competing for limited positions and hoping they will land a

00:09:55 - 00:10:42
role that sets them up for the rest of [music] their career. One Hua interviews a mother who had sponsored her 18-year-old daughter’s surgery. Miss Tong had this to say about her decision. My daughter [music] asked for the surgery. I have no way she wasn’t satisfied with her looks. If it was 20 years ago in my generation, I would ask her to keep the [music] original appearance she was born with. But society is so competitive today. The competition for jobs and every kind of resource is so fierce. [music] If a

00:10:19 - 00:11:10
crease in her eyelids can make her happier and more competitive, why not? Miss Tong sponsored the surgery [music] out of practicality. She believed greater beauty could lead to advantages, the effect of accumulating beauty capital. [music] 23-year-old Chen Jing arrived at the same conclusion, but she suffered several setbacks before making [music] up her mind. I was naive to believe that if I studied hard, I would get a good job. So when pretty girls in my class were busy hanging out with boys, I stayed in the library. But when

00:10:44 - 00:11:34
we were about to graduate, pretty girls and boys could get employed more easily than me. It’s so [music] unfair. Chen later spent all her savings from part-time jobs and borrowed money from friends to pay for [music] a double eyelid surgery and nose job. Her ending remark was, “It is an age of beauty. Being good-looking is capital.” [music] In these situations, surgery is not as much of a want as it is a need. When there is extremely [music] fierce competition, any advantage goes and

00:11:09 - 00:11:54
beauty becomes a valuable strength. However, though leveraging beauty as capital works [music] in the short term, maybe it really did make a difference in landing that job. Playing this game, unfortunately, only further reinforces a system that discriminates [music] based on looks and disempowers women in the long run. It’s a classic damned if you do [music] and damned if you don’t situation.

(you’re) damned if you do and damned if you don’t
phrase
informal
—used to say that in a specific situation a person can be blamed or considered wrong no matter what he or she does

If you get surgery, you perpetuate the system and reinforce [music] a beauty standard that should

00:11:31 - 00:12:18
not be held. If you don’t get surgery, you might find yourself witnessing people who do get work done [music] reaping the benefits of it. Many of you might be thinking, well, if competition is so fierce, why don’t the men all get surgery, too? [music] Competition is fierce for men, but women often find themselves in a more challenging situation because of discrimination. [music] To be clear, it’s illegal in China now for workplaces to only hire a certain [music] gender, but this law has

00:11:55 - 00:12:42
historically been hard to enforce. So, there are still cases of employers giving preference [music] to male candidates. When Hua and her research also spoke to hiring managers, and their responses gives us very valuable insight into the situation. Keep [music] in mind this conversation was from a decade ago, so it was a different time, but some of this thinking may still remain today. One hiring manager, Mr. Liang, [music] says this, “If a man and a woman have similar qualifications, I generally

00:12:18 - 00:13:05
prefer a man. I have no personal prejudices against women. [music] My basic principle is to choose the best for the company. Women cannot travel alone like men. Besides, they will cause a loss to the company [music] when they have babies.” “If a pretty woman and a normal-looking woman have similar qualifications, then of course, I choose the pretty one. That’s natural. [music] So, for women, they face discrimination on two levels, based on their gender [music] and based on their looks. And

00:12:42 - 00:13:26
just because we have eyes and we have our own preferences on what makes [music] an attractive face does not mean we can just create a hidden criteria for women to look a certain way when their appearance [music] has nothing to do with the role they perform. Like when the Hunan government in 2004 required female applicants [music] to have a pair of symmetrical breasts in the application to be a civil servant. I’m going [music] to take a wild guess that they did not require male applicants to

00:13:04 - 00:13:54
have a pair of symmetrical balls. Grad season and job [music] hunts are just one stage in life when anxiety over an uncertain future reaches a peak. The other time for women, especially, is in marriage, and we’ll find appearances again [music] being both the problem and the so-called solution. Much of the ties between marriage and appearance anxiety comes from the long time emphasis [music] in China on women being beautiful. For example, the saying lang cai nu describes an ideal couple where

00:13:29 - 00:14:20
the guy is talented [music] and the lady is, well, beautiful. Looks are therefore easily tied to a woman’s worth, and this anxiety is intensified when women look to date or marry. In one interview conducted by Wen Hua, she spoke to a woman in her [music] 30s who looked every part of a successful, confident, modern woman. Mrs. Gao was a manager at a big IT [music] company and doing great career-wise for herself. But to Wen Hua’s surprise, Mrs. Gao revealed she was considering plastic surgery.

00:13:55 - 00:14:47
Mrs. Gao shares [music] that she had been in two failed relationships over the past 8 years, and she noticed that both her exes married the same [music] type of woman, one that had a small face, big eyes, white skin, and long, straight hair. In comparison, Mrs. Gao said she was not the type of person to spend an hour putting on makeup, and [music] her exes actually brought that up to her, complaining that she lacked femininity. Mrs. Gao had been confident in who she was, but as she gets older, she finds herself under greater pressure

00:14:21 - 00:15:14
to conform. My close friend said that if I want to have a happy ending for a relationship, dress and act in a softer and more feminine way. They are probably [music] right. My personality is too strong, and so is my appearance. My facial contour is too rigid, which makes me less feminine. I can work on my temperament to be more feminine, but as for my looks, I can do nothing except go under the scalpel. My face is short and wide, a kind of squarish shape. I’ve heard [music] that I can undergo an

00:14:47 - 00:15:38
operation to have a thinner and smoother face. I had believed that a woman’s ability should be more important than her beauty, [music] but maybe it’s time for a change. It really hurts hearing Mrs. Gao talk about her features in this [music] way. A woman is worth much more than her looks, though society seems to often hammer home the opposite message. [music] The irony in calling this process natural selection is not lost on me, but that’s what we’re starting to see. People are noticing that

00:15:13 - 00:16:01
good-looking individuals are the ones that survive and get picked first, whether it’s in jobs or in marriage, so they [music] evolve to have this trait. I know in these instances plastic surgery was undergone mainly for the purpose of practicality and not vanity. [music] In the next part, however, we’ll be looking into the cases where women do get plastic surgery to look better for themselves. But remember, even such serving motives come with social benefits, and this narrative [music] is

00:15:35 - 00:16:21
endlessly pushed to us by the media. >> [music] >> We all look different. We have different eyes, nose, lips, and face shapes, and that’s part of the charm. But if I got you to picture a face that meets the beauty ideal in your culture, especially if it was a woman’s face, you would probably give me a description [music] that’s very similar to what someone else in your culture would say. The media has pushed a very narrow definition of beauty, >> [music] >> and most of us won’t meet these

00:16:01 - 00:16:49
standards. Take Chinese beauty standards. How is a population where half the people are monolid [music] going to meet the ideal for double eyelids, or having a tall and slim nose, or a sharp feline jaw, when these are not the traits the majority [music] of Chinese people would have? The answer appears to be, if you don’t have these ideal features, [music] then you should probably do something about it. The consumption of media, in particular beauty or fashion-related content, is [music] powerful in shaping

00:16:25 - 00:17:14
our ideas of beauty, how we feel about ourselves, and our attitudes towards its common fixes, [music] makeup, diet, and plastic surgery. Many women that were interviewed in the 2000s had a fashion magazine in their hand as they waited in surgery lounges. These days, you’d have a photo of someone and tell your surgeon you want this person’s nose or that kind of lip shape. But the thing is, [music] how sure are we that the photo that’s being brought into the clinic as a reference is even real at all? So many

00:16:50 - 00:17:37
of the photos we’re seeing on social media have been retouched and edited, or is literally AI, and you cannot [music] tell. When we digest content, we don’t think about whether it’s edited or not. We simply see it, sometimes [music] compare ourselves to it, and always feel bad in the aftermath. Our exposure to edited content warps our idea [music] of beauty and erodes our worth in our own eyes. We see our unedited features looking back at us in the mirror, and we become convinced that we need [music] to

00:17:13 - 00:18:06
buy more products or add more steps into our routine. If we become immensely dissatisfied with ourselves, we may even consider surgery. [music] But what we are trying to bring to life may have never existed, never been real. Portrait calls the intersection of digital appearances and reality the age of simulation. [music] A simulation is the collapse of the real with the imaginary, the true with the false. And the media does not focus on distinguishing between the true and the false. Rather, media tries its best to

00:17:39 - 00:18:35
make the imaginary real. Take this article from Good Housekeeping published in the early 2000s as a normal [music] plastic surgery to its readers. If it really makes you look more beautiful and young, if it only needs a few hours, and if it is totally affordable with a credit card, why not undergo cosmetic surgery? This is an unwritten eternal truth. Everyone, not just men, loves beautiful women. Even if you have never planned to be the most beautiful woman in the world, you should not keep dwelling on what you are dissatisfied

00:18:07 - 00:18:57
with in your body. Dissatisfaction is dissatisfaction. Nobody cares whether your body is a natural unaltered one. It is about beauty and happiness. In other words, don’t fix your insecurities. That’s so boring. When we say work on yourself, we obviously mean get work done on yourself. Imagine being impressionable and young, and instead of being encouraged to think about how these beauty ideals are perpetuated in the first place, and whether or not they even obligated to meet it, they’re

00:18:32 - 00:19:23
instead encouraged to go through surgery without ever challenging the narrative that [music] beauty is where they should focus their ambitions in. Major surgeries carry risks and are a significant expense, [music] but it’s about beauty and happiness, not health. And what’s an expense anyways, when you can just put it on a credit card, right? Aside from media influences, [music] specific parts of Chinese culture may also encourage Chinese women to undertake surgery. Chinese participants in Wu and other study talked about how

00:18:58 - 00:19:51
much of Chinese culture is rooted in self-criticism and in striving for perfection. Confucianism advocated [music] for self-improvement, and this mentality, coupled with commercially driven media interest, can result [music] in Chinese participants being more open and pursuing surgery to better their appearances for themselves or for practical purposes. So, how do [music] Chinese women now view beauty with all its evolving expectations and increasing relevance in their lives? [music] Ma spoke to Chinese women who are 18 to 25

00:19:24 - 00:20:11
years old, and when asked about beauty, all of them naturally split it up into concepts of inner and [music] outer beauty. They all agreed that outer beauty mattered, but emphasized that pursuing it was not sustainable as a woman will inevitably age, thus falling out of favor [music] with mainstream beauty ideals. One respondent reflects on how receiving compliments on her looks became [music] a burden to her as she got older. If a person praises me, saying, “You are so beautiful today,” I

00:19:48 - 00:20:38
will feel that [music] it is a burden. I was thinking that many girls were given such a compliment when they were young, and it should be said that such a compliment is like sugar water. After they drink too much, they will be thirsty for more and more. This validation we receive for our looks is often gratifying in the short [music] term, but anxiety-inducing in the long term because looks don’t last, or at least youth doesn’t last. In contrast, inner beauty [music] does not fade. It only grows for a woman as she works on

00:20:13 - 00:20:59
it. Ma’s sample of respondents were highly educated, and they found [music] working on their inner beauty as a way to combat against the media’s focus on a woman’s physical appearance and the patriarchal values that tie a woman’s worth to her looks. [music] Pursuing inner beauty allowed respondents to feel beautiful as they aged. One professor [music] was described by a respondent as having a lot of chizhi, which translates to a confident aura that’s linked with being cultured. Focusing on inner beauty

00:20:36 - 00:21:25
seemed [music] to empower these respondents. The exact effects plastic surgery have on women that have [music] undergone such procedures is debated. You’ll hear different stories and experiences from women, and in papers, you’ll also see conflicting findings. For some, after their procedure, they feel positive about the results and more comfortable in their own skin. [music] For others, the results of their procedure worsens issues of body dysmorphia and depression. One doctor from the Chinese Medical Association was

00:21:00 - 00:21:48
rather brutal in his remark. “Surgery only improves a person’s appearance. [music] There is no improvement of their knowledge, ability, or disposition at all. What these women really need is a psychologist, [music] not a plastic surgeon. A common view among those who’ve undergone plastic surgery is that the why is the most crucial part. If the choice to undergo surgery is driven [music] by external validation, seeking approval, recognition, or because they’re getting pressured by others, the

00:21:25 - 00:22:13
procedure often leads [music] to regret. But, if it’s done for oneself, the risk tends to be lower. And, one respondent who has gotten surgery and liked it said the following about her decision and how she sees inner and outer beauty. “I wanted to become more beautiful. I wanted to be better. It might sound [music] like I’m emphasizing outer beauty and ignoring inner beauty, but actually, I am not. Of course, inner beauty is essential, but a beautiful image is the start to letting [music]

00:21:49 - 00:22:36
your inner self shine. As far as I’m concerned, the pursuit of outer beauty isn’t contradictory with having a good character. If I can become beautiful both [music] inside and out, why not?” And, this is a very fair point, too. Women can pursue outward beauty and develop their inner character at the same time. In the end, [music] it is their body, but hopefully, from our discussion today, you’re able to see that much of their choice [music] is really dictated or influenced by factors

00:22:12 - 00:23:05
outside of their control. The media generates an enormous [music] desire for perfection and has opened our eyes to everything we are not. Our exploration on the rise of plastic surgery in China reveals how the desire for change is driven by both vanity and [music] practical purposes. Beauty is more often leveraged as capital in highly competitive societies, [music] which is what we’re seeing in China. And, in combination with the media making these procedures seem less intimidating and more accessible, surgery has [music]

00:22:39 - 00:23:33
become normalized. That being said, the choice to undergo surgery should not be taken lightly. It always comes with risks. As we’ve examined [music] today, in certain cultures like China, the payoff just happens to be all worth it. If you enjoyed my breakdown of plastic surgery culture in China, please make sure to subscribe. The research for this video took me so long. So, I would really appreciate it if you could sub. A big thank you to my patrons as always for their incredible support and I will

00:23:05 - 00:23:09
see you in the next one. Bye.