00:00:00 - 00:00:46
I fought with many warriors in my time. They were far stronger than all of us put together, and they died. They died facing enemies and threats that scared me far less than this one. That’s the line. That’s the one everybody pulled out of the Avengers Doomsday trailer and stuck under a sad piano. And I don’t think a single one of us actually heard what was being said in it because it is being said by somebody who should have no way of knowing it. That’s Thor, and Thor has never met Doctor Doom, or at

00:00:23 - 00:01:07
least that’s what we’ve all been assuming. Now, read that again slowly cuz that is not a guess. That is not a god of thunder doing a little motivational speech before a big fight. That is a man ranking something, and you cannot rank a threat you have never met. So, the theory going around right now, and honestly, the more I sat with it, the more it wrecked me, is that Thor’s big speech in Avengers Tower isn’t the beginning of his story in this movie. It’s the middle. Thor has already met

00:00:45 - 00:01:31
Doctor Doom by the time he says those words. He’s already fought him. He’s already lost. And something he saw during that fight scared him so badly that by the time he walks into that room, he isn’t recruiting the Avengers. He’s warning them. And if that’s true, then every weird thing Thor does in that trailer, including the thing he does to Steve Rogers, stops being weird and starts being the smartest piece of foreshadowing Marvel has put in a trailer in years. Let’s get into it.

00:01:08 - 00:01:57
First, I want to establish something because this whole theory lives or dies on it. Thor’s words only mean something if Thor’s experience means something. So, let’s actually look at the receipts. Thor has fought Hela, the goddess of death, firstborn of Odin, strong enough to catch Mjolnir in midair and crush it in her hand like it was a soda can. The hammer that nobody could lift, she broke it, and she did it in about 4 seconds while making a face like she was mildly annoyed. Thor lost that fight. He lost

00:01:32 - 00:02:22
an eye. He lost Asgard. He had to literally end his own civilization to beat her. Thor has fought Thanos with the Infinity Gauntlet on. And here’s the part people forget. Thor actually won that exchange. He landed Stormbreaker in Thanos’s chest. He had him. The only reason the universe turned to dust that day is that Thor was so angry, he wanted Thanos to feel it, and he went for the chest instead of the head. Thor knows exactly how strong Thanos was because Thor is the only person who came within

00:01:57 - 00:02:45
two inches of stopping him. Thor has fought Gorr the God Butcher, a guy whose entire job description, whose whole personality is murdering gods. Gorr had the Necrosword. He was killing beings like Thor across the entire universe, and [music] he was good at it. Thor beat him, barely, and only by handing his own daughter over to the universe. Thor has stood in front of Surtur, a fire demon the size of a mountain, and said, “Do your worst.” And he’s fought the Celestials, he’s fought Malekith, he’s

00:02:21 - 00:03:05
fought his way through losing Jane, which honestly might be the one that hurt the most. The man has a highlight reel that would make Hercules go and have a lie down.

A highlight reel is a short video compilation that features only the most exciting, important, or best moments from a larger body of footage

That is the resume. That is the man talking. So, when Thor looks at a room full of Avengers and says, “I have fought warriors stronger than all of you combined, and they died fighting things that scared me less than this.” He’s not being dramatic. He’s doing math. He’s comparing, and comparing requires data, which brings us

00:02:43 - 00:03:35
to the actual speech, because I want to go through it properly, line by line, the way it’s cut in the trailer. Thor says, “I’ve fought with many warriors in my time. They were far stronger than all of us put together, and they died. They died facing enemies and threats that scared me far less than this one. Then, everything that they sacrificed will be for nothing if we do not stand together. Then, put aside your petty squabbles. Then, if you return, you will return as brothers and sisters. And then, mark my

00:03:09 - 00:03:55
words.” And somewhere in that sequence, we get the line, “We’re going to need a miracle.” Now, guys, Thor, he does not talk like this. Think about every version of Thor we’ve had since Ragnarok. The guy is a comedian. The guy calls people lackwit. The guy got drunk and gained weight and played Fortnite for 5 years. Even in Infinity War, when he is at his absolute lowest, and he’s telling Rocket about everything he’s lost, there’s still a swing in it. There’s still fight in it. He’s still

00:03:32 - 00:04:12
saying he’s going to kill Thanos. This is different. This is a funeral voice. “If you return, you will return as brothers and sisters.” That’s a man who has already counted how many of them are not coming back. “Put aside your petty squabbles.” That’s a man who has seen exactly how little their arguments are going to matter. And “We’re going to need a miracle” is not a battle cry, y’all. That’s a surrender wrapped in a hope. Something happened to Thor before

00:03:52 - 00:04:38
that room. So, here’s the theory in full. The Avengers Tower scene is not Thor’s first scene in Avengers: Doomsday. Thor’s first scene is Thor fighting Doctor Doom alone somewhere [music] else earlier in the movie. He loses, and during that fight, he sees something under Doom’s mask or in Doom’s face that he was not ready for. And then he goes to Earth, walks into that room, and tries to explain to a group of people who have never met Victor Von Doom what he just went up against. And

00:04:15 - 00:05:03
the reason that theory has legs is that we have actually seen part of that fight. Marvel’s D 23 footage, the stuff that was shown to a room full of people and then described absolutely everywhere, has Thor going at Doom with Stormbreaker, and Doom stops it, not blocks it, not deflects it, stops the axe that killed Thanos with two fingers, and then hits Thor with a green energy blast and takes him off his feet. The dude stops Stormbreaker with two fingers. That’s badass, and it’s also

00:04:39 - 00:05:24
completely terrifying because the last person who stopped a weapon like that so casually was Thanos with a full gauntlet, and Doom is doing it bare-handed. Now, I need to be honest with you about something before we go further because this is a theory video, and I’m not going to pretend it’s a confirmation video. Trailer order is not movie order. Editors cut trailers to sell you a feeling, not a timeline. So, nobody can tell you for a fact that the Thor and Doom fight happens before the

00:05:02 - 00:05:53
Avengers Tower speech. That is the theory. Marvel has not confirmed it. But, here’s what makes me lean into it anyway. Thor’s speech contains information, not emotion, information. He describes Doom as a threat of a specific size. He compares him to things he has personally fought, and in the footage of the fight, Thor is not surprised by Doom. Watch how he goes in. He goes in committed, full swing, no hesitation, like a man who already knows a hesitation would cost him. That is not how you open against someone you’ve

00:05:27 - 00:06:13
never seen. That’s how you open against someone who already beat you once. And then there’s the part of this theory that actually made me sit up because it explains the single strangest beat in the whole trailer. Thor does something to Steve Rogers. In the Avengers Tower footage, Thor walks up to Steve, and he says, “Hey, pal.” And then he says, “It’s not possible.” And then, and this is the bit, Steve summons Mjolnir. The hammer flies across the room into Steve’s hand with Thor standing right

00:05:50 - 00:06:38
there watching it happen. Everybody clipped that moment as a hype moment. Cap’s worthy. Cap’s got the hammer again. Let’s go. And yeah, it rules. But ask yourself the boring question. Why does Thor say it’s not possible? And why is Mjolnir even in the room? Because if the theory is right that is not a reunion, that is a test. Think about what Thor saw in that fight. If Thor looked at Doctor Doom and saw a face he recognized, and we all know whose face is under that mask because we have seen

00:06:14 - 00:07:01
Robert Downey Jr. in the suit, then Thor has just learned the worst possible lesson. He has learned that the people he loves can come back wearing the wrong person. He has learned that a familiar face is now the most dangerous thing in the universe. So he comes to Earth, and the first thing he sees is Steve Rogers, who he has not seen since Steve was a hundred and something years old sitting on a bench by a lake. And Thor says, “Hey pal,” which is Steve’s line, that’s Steve and Bucky’s word, and then he

00:06:38 - 00:07:27
says, “It’s not possible.” And then Mjolnir moves. Because Mjolnir is the only lie detector in the Marvel universe that has never been wrong. Only the worthy can lift it. Not the strong, not the clever, not the well-disguised. The worthy. Hela could hold it because she was Odin’s firstborn, and the hammer was key to that bloodline. Fine. But nobody has ever faked worthiness. And the guy who has worn other people’s faces in this universe, the guy who has literally sat on a throne wearing Odin’s face for

00:07:02 - 00:07:48
years, the guy who once turned himself into Captain America just to mess with Thor’s head, that guy could never lift it. Loki tried in the very first Avengers era in Asgard. Loki has stood in front of that hammer, and it has told him no every single time. So if you are Thor, and you have just watched a familiar face try to kill you, and you walk into a room and see a friend who should not be standing there looking like that, you don’t hug him. You hand him the hammer because the hammer cannot

00:07:25 - 00:08:09
be tricked. And the hammer says, “Yes, that’s Steve.” That’s not a hype moment. That’s Thor exhaling for the first time in the whole movie. Quick thing before I get to the part that made me put my phone down. I checked the numbers the other day, and only about 4% of you watching are actually subscribed. So if you’re enjoying this, hit subscribe and smash that like cuz I’d love to get that to 10% and the algorithm genuinely does not show you the next one unless you do.

00:07:47 - 00:08:34
Also, we’re on Spotify now. So, if you’re at work or at the gym or sitting in traffic hating your life, you can just put Nerd Drop on and let me talk theories at you while you do something else. Same videos, no screen. Links in the description. [music] But anyway, back to Thor because there’s a piece of this that I buried and I need to put it on the table now. The Doomsday teaser, the one that dropped with all the character reveals, ended with a code. And fans being fans, people decoded it. And the decode points at a

00:08:10 - 00:09:00
timestamp in Avengers: Endgame. 1 hour, 17 minutes, 20 seconds. You know what’s happening at that point in Endgame? That’s the 2012 New York sequence. That is Loki standing in front of Thor and Tony having just been handed the Tesseract in the middle of the scene where Captain America fights Captain America and whispers “Hail Hydra” at an elevator full of SHIELD agents. I want to be really clear because this is exactly the kind of thing that gets turned into a fake headline. That decode

00:08:35 - 00:09:24
is fan work. Marvel has not come out and said, “Yes, go watch 1 hour 17 in Endgame.” It is a community read of a teaser graphic. So, treat it as a theory, not a fact. But as a theory, oh boy. Because what that timestamp points at is the single moment in the entire MCU where the Avengers could not tell who was who. Two Captains America’s in a hallway. Loki with a face that isn’t his. A Tesseract going missing because nobody checked. If Marvel wanted to hand you a pointer that said, “The thing you

00:09:00 - 00:09:46
should be afraid of in Doomsday is not knowing who you’re standing next to,” that is the exact frame you would point at. And it lines up terrifyingly well with Thor saying, “It’s not possible” to a man’s face. Because think about what that scene in Endgame actually teaches the Avengers if any of them were paying attention, which they were not. It teaches them that the most dangerous thing in the world isn’t a bigger army. It’s one guy wearing the right face, walking into the right room, and being

00:09:23 - 00:10:06
handed the exact thing he came for while everybody else stands around nodding. Loki didn’t fight anyone for that Tesseract. He picked it up off the floor because the people in that room were busy. And if Doom’s whole move in this movie is being the guy nobody questions, then Thor is the only Avenger who got a look at the trick before the show started. Now, I promise you this was a theory video, so let’s be proper about it and go through the other readings. Because there are two more explanations

00:09:45 - 00:10:30
for Thor’s behavior that I think are genuinely competitive, and one of them might actually be better than mine. Reading number, sorry, I’m not doing numbers. Let me just say it. The first alternative is that this isn’t our Thor at all, that it’s a variant. Think about it. Doomsday is a multiverse movie. We have confirmed Fox era X-Men showing up. We have incursions in play. We have a version of Victor Von Doom who looks like Tony Stark. Multiverse is not background texture in this movie, it’s

00:10:07 - 00:10:49
the plot. So, what if the Thor giving that speech has already lived through this? What if there’s a universe where Doom came and Doom won [music] and the Avengers died and one Thor crawled out of it and went looking for the next Earth along to warn. That reading fixes everything the easy way. Of course, he’s talking like a man at a funeral. He’s already been to the funeral. Of course, he’s measuring Doom against things he’s fought. He’s fought Doom. Of course, he says it’s not possible when he sees

00:10:28 - 00:11:14
Steve Rogers alive and young enough to swing a hammer because in his universe Steve died or Steve was something else or Steve was the one wearing the mask. thing is, Marvel has done this exact before. A guy from a dead timeline showing up to tell the heroes what’s coming. That’s half of What If. That’s the entire pitch of a dozen comic events. It’s a clean, cheap, emotionally loaded way to give the audience stakes in minute 10. [music] And there’s one detail in the trailer that honestly fits

00:10:51 - 00:11:35
this reading better than it fits mine, which is Thor’s look. It changes across this footage and people have been arguing about it for months, whether that’s two different points in the movie or two different Thors. I don’t think that proves anything on its own because Marvel’s hair and beard continuity has never once been a reliable narrator. But, if you wanted to hide a hint that you’re watching more than one Thor, that’s exactly where you’d put it. The second alternative is the one I keep

00:11:13 - 00:12:01
going back and forth on, and it’s that Thor didn’t fight Doom at all. He saw him. Because this has happened to Thor before and we all watched it and most of us forgot. Age of Ultron. Thor walks into a cave in a mountain in Norway, puts his hands in some water, and gets shown the future. He sees the Infinity Stones. He sees Asgard burning. He sees his friends dead on the floor. He comes out of that water absolutely shaken, and he spends the rest of the movie behaving like a man who knows something he can’t

00:11:37 - 00:12:22
prove. And nobody in that movie takes him seriously, and he was right about every single bit of it. Thor is canonically the Avenger who gets shown things. So, the second reading is that somewhere between Love and Thunder and now, Thor got another one of those, a vision, not a fight, a preview. And a vision would explain something a fight doesn’t, which is the specific flavor of Thor’s fear. Because when you fight someone, you learn their strength. When you’re shown something, you learn the

00:11:59 - 00:12:44
outcome. “And they died, they died facing enemies that scared me far less than this one.” Is a man describing an outcome, not a punch. I’m going to be honest, if Marvel does it that way with Thor as the guy who has seen the ending and can’t make anybody listen, that’s the better movie. That’s a Cassandra. That’s tragedy, and it rhymes with the first time where nobody believed him and Ultron happened anyway. But here’s where I land, and here’s why I think the fight

00:12:22 - 00:13:05
version is still the one. A vision explains the fear. A vision does not explain Mjolnir. If Thor had only been shown a future, he’d walk into that room and start shouting about a prophecy. He wouldn’t say it’s not possible to Steve Rogers specifically, and he definitely wouldn’t need Steve to prove himself with a hammer. The hammer test only makes sense if Thor has a live, personal, recent reason to doubt that faces are telling the truth. And the only thing in this entire movie that

00:12:43 - 00:13:31
does that is standing in front of a man in a green cloak and seeing Tony Stark looking back at him, which brings us to the counter argument. And I want to give it properly because it’s the strongest one against everything I’ve just said. The boring explanation is that someone just told Thor in the D23 footage, Sue Storm briefs the heroes. The Fantastic Four know exactly who Victor von Doom is because of course they do. He’s their guy. He’s been their guy for 60 years of comics. So, you could very reasonably

00:13:07 - 00:13:59
say, “Look, the Fantastic Four show up, they explain what Doom is, Thor listens, Thor relays it to the Avengers in his big-ass Guardian voice.” Done. No earlier fight. No vision. No variant. Just a briefing. And that’s fair. That is completely fair, and it might be the answer. But a briefing gives you facts. It does not give you the voice Thor is using. You can tell a god of thunder that a man in Latveria is dangerous and powerful and has an energy signature nobody can read. Thor’s response to that

00:13:34 - 00:14:19
is, “Bring him to me.” That’s his response to everything. That’s been his response since 2011. Information makes Thor confident, only experience makes Thor quiet. And he is so quiet in that room, y’all. Mark my words. That’s what you say when you already know you’re going to be right and you hate it. So, let’s put the whole thing together cuz I think when you line it up in order, it actually reads like a movie. Thor encounters Doctor Doom, maybe on Earth, maybe somewhere else. Maybe in the

00:13:56 - 00:14:42
moment Doom makes his move on whatever he’s collecting. Thor does what Thor does and swings first. [music] And Doom catches Stormbreaker between two fingers, which should not be physically possible. And then puts Thor on the floor with a blast of green energy. And in that moment, whether it’s the mask coming loose or Doom choosing to show him, Thor sees the face. And it’s a face he buried because Thor was there. Thor watched Tony Stark snap his fingers and die. Thor stood at that lake with

00:14:19 - 00:15:05
everybody else. Out of all the Avengers, Thor is the one who has lost the most people and the one who takes each one hardest because he is a thousand years old and he still has not learned how to not care. He lost his mother, his father, his brother twice, his best friends, [music] his home, his hammer, his daughter’s childhood. The man is made of grief with a cape on. So, you show him Tony’s face on the thing that just beat him. And you don’t just scare him, you break something. And then he

00:14:42 - 00:15:23
comes to Earth and he can’t say it. Watch the speech again with this in your head and notice what Thor never does. He never names Doom. He never explains him. He says, “This one.” That’s it. That’s all he can get out. He talks around it like people talk around the thing they can’t say out loud yet. And he says, “Mark my words.” Guys, the last time Thor told a room full of people that something was coming and they didn’t fully listen, we got Ultron. The time

00:15:02 - 00:15:51
before that, we got Thanos. And Thor spent Infinity War telling anyone who’d sit still that he had seen what this thing does and nobody moved fast enough. Thor is zero for two on being believed and both times the bill came due. And now he’s a dad. That’s the part that gets me. Thor has love now. He’s got a kid he adopted out of the ashes of the worst week of of life and the whole arc of Love and Thunder was him deciding that caring about something again was worth the risk of losing it. So, when

00:15:27 - 00:16:07
Thor walks into Avengers Tower and says, “If you return, you will return as brothers and sisters.” He’s a parent making peace with the fact that he might not come home. That’s not a hype speech. That’s a man writing a will. So, what’s actually confirmed and what’s theory? Let’s be clean about it because I’d rather you walk out of here knowing the difference than feeling hyped on stuff I made up. Confirmed, or at least shown, Thor fights Doctor Doom. Doom stops

00:15:47 - 00:16:37
Stormbreaker with two fingers and hits him with green energy. Thor gives a speech to the Avengers comparing Doom to warriors stronger than all of them who died facing lesser threats. [music] Thor says, “Hey, pal.” And it’s not possible to Steve Rogers. Steve summons Mjolnir. Sue Storm [music] briefs the heroes on who Victor is. Doom wears Tony Stark’s face because Robert Downey Jr. is playing him and Marvel has not hidden that for 1 second. Theory, that the fight happens before the speech, that

00:16:12 - 00:16:59
Thor saw Tony’s face during it, that the Mjolnir moment is Thor verifying Steve rather than celebrating him, that the teaser code pointing at Endgame is intentional. That this Thor might be a variant, that Thor might have had a vision instead. All of that is us reading the footage. None of it is Marvel talking. But, here’s the thing about this one that I can’t shake, and it’s why I think it’s the best Doomsday theory going right now. It doesn’t need Marvel to confirm anything to work. It

00:16:35 - 00:17:23
just needs you to accept one small, almost boring idea, which is that trailers don’t show you scenes in order. Flip two scenes around, and Thor stops being a guy giving a speech and becomes the only person in that room who already knows how this ends. And honestly, I hope they do it. I hope the movie opens on Thor and Doom. No context, no Avengers, just a god swinging the axe that killed Thanos, and a man in green catching it like he’s catching a ball his kid threw. And then Thor stands up,

00:16:59 - 00:17:43
and Doom lets him see the face, and Thor goes very still, and then we cut to Avengers Tower, and he’s already talking like somebody died because the scariest thing a movie can do is not show you the monster, it show you the strongest guy in the room after. I fought with many warriors in my time. They were far stronger than all of us put together, and they died. He’s not warning them about Doom, guys. He’s telling them what losing feels like cuz he’s already done it once and he has got [music] about 2

00:17:21 - 00:17:29
hours to make sure the rest of them don’t have to find out.