The World Against Manon? (Hiatus or Kicked out?) đ«Ł
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BsBSgtkmjak
æ äœè
This video is brought to you by Squarespace,an all-in-one platform for building your brand and growing your business online.Hello, my beautiful doves.As some of you may have guessed,I am Asian American, surprise! (laughs), (birds chirping) (curtains whirring) (cat meowing) (birds chirping continues), And like many Asian Americans,I went through a phase where I just about worshiped the K-pop industry.For me, this phase took place during sophomore junior year, of high school to the point where I would wake up at 4:00 AM, before class started, just so that, I could watch my favorite groups performing on Mnet, because you know the time difference.This was also the first time that I discovered the Korean beauty industry, because K-pop and beauty go hand in hand.Idols are constantly promoting products, doing product placements.Similar to Sydney Sweeneyâs never ending partnership with corporate America.Most idols also got plastic surgery,and this was something I was really shocked by at the time.
because in America, if a pop star got plastic surgery,it was like a major talking point, derogatory, people are really mean about it,so a lot of stars try to hide the fact that they got procedures,but in Korea, itâs very blatant.You can easily find before photos of every single idol,and thereâs just not a lot of stigma.People actually praise the results when theyâre good.At the time I was in awe of these surgical transformations.I truly believed that every idol looked so much better post plastic surgery.Mind you, almost all the before photos of them are, from when they were like 14 years old, and still clearly growing into their faces.But thatâs besides the point.I was drinking the Kool-Aid.I was chugging the Kool-Aid,and as a result, I became obsessed with what kinda work I would get done.When I finally got the disposable income to fly to Korea, and pay for my new face,like this was so locked into my future plans.Obviously over time the plans have changed, and I started becoming really upset.
with what the plastic surgery industry has done, to us as a society on a global scale,in terms of the Korean surgery industry,I became much more informed about the oppression that dark skinned, or mixed Koreans experience, as well as the experiences, of other demographics of Asians who are affected by Koreaâs soft power.Like as a Vietnamese woman, it really disturbs me, how looking Korean has become an aspiration, for some of my community.Meanwhile, looking Vietnamese, or looking Southeast Asian is often weaponized as an insult, by East Asians.I also watched shows like âSingleâs Inferno,â which is a Korean dating show,and the first season was very controversial, because some of the male contestants would say,literally point blank to the camera, that they liked a girl purely because she had pale skin,like nothing about her personality.Also, to say that thereâs a lot going on in the Korean beauty industry,and I found that over time itâs just gotten more, and more powerful, especially on a global scale.
So I wanna talk about it.As I said, I am Vietnamese, Iâm not Korean, and I canât read Korean, so thereâs obviously discourse, that Iâm missing, but I did my best, and I referred to a lot of information, from Elise Huâs book, âFlawless: Lessons in Looks, and Culture from the K-Beauty Capital,â who is an award-winning journalist,and she was NPRs first bureau Chief in Seoul,and I highly recommend reading her book if this subject interests you.Itâs very comprehensive.- Off to Korea. - Off to Korea.(transition clicks) - [Tourist] Today Iâm getting double eyelid surgery.- [Tourist 2] Lip filler, and Botox.- [Tourist 3] Liposuction.- One of the fastest growing sectors in the travel industry, medical tourism.(upbeat energetic music), (upbeat energetic music continues), (upbeat energetic music continues) (keyboard buttons clacking), (TV static buzzing) - If youâve been looking for a way to build your website,but HTML and CSS and all that sound intimidating.Squarespace is an amazing platform that offers tons.
of customization options and pre-made templates.A lot of people use Squarespace to host their stores,and thatâs because itâs just super easy.You can list any product from something physical to subscriptions to downloads.Iâm currently using Squarespace as a portfolio both, for my book club and for my video essays.As an example, for this most recent video, the work cited was actually so long,it maxed out YouTubeâs description limits.So I created a page on my site to host all these references just for you.Check out squarespace.com for free trial, and when youâre ready to launch,go to squarespace.com/MinaLe, to get 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.(TV static buzzing) (upbeat energetic music), (transition beeps) (tourist speaking in foreign language), (guide speaking in foreign language) (tourist speaking in foreign language), - So first, I feel like we need to discuss, what the beauty standards even are in Korea.There are many, but I would pin it down to big eyes.
and double eyelids, thinness, high nasal bridges
bridge
the ~ of sbâs nose [sing.] the hard part at the top of the nose, between the eyes
,a V-line jaw and pale skin.There is an emphasis on looking glowy and youthful,hence why aegyo sal, the small puff, of skin found under the eyes is often highlighted as well, as this feature apparently adds a youthful charm to the face.
In English, aegyo-sal is usually called under-eye puff or under-eye fullness.
These standards are also pretty unisex.While I think there are some crossover ideals, like the big eyes and the thin bodies,overall, Korean beauty standards are pretty distinct, from Western beauty standards,and thatâs why I find it extremely irritating, whenever I hear Americans saying things like,âOh, everyone in Asia just wants to look white.â, In actuality, the favoring of white skin in Korea,âwhiteâ in quotes, predates Western colonization.It doesnât refer to race, it refers, to the paleness associated with being high class, during the Gojoseon period, which ended in 108 BCE.The belief was that the white skin suggested, a labor free life away from the sun.Similarly, regarding double eyelids, Elise Hu notes.
in her book âFlawless,â, that itâs actually East Asian movie stars with this feature, who are considered the ideal.She writes in East Asia,the double-eyelidded Hwang Shin-Hye, not Meg Ryan, had the most sought after face.No offense to the beautiful Meg Ryan, of course.She also reports that of the hundreds of people she talked to for her book,not a single person said the motivation, for plastic surgery in Korea is to look more European.Furthermore, anthropologists, and scholars have uniformly found that the importance, of local cultural dynamics trumps, outside influences when it comes to health and beauty norms.Well, yes, there are some traces, of European beauty baked into the Korean beauty ideal.Sophie Jin argues that this was not the result of idealizing whiteness,but the result of Koreans attempting, to formulate a new national identity separate, from their former colonizer, Japan.She writes for the Journal of Contemporary Asian Studies.âFor a country shaped by foreign influence, a desire.
for a new identity stemmed from an âAnti-otherâ sentiment, or a rejection of foreign powers.Thus, by drawing on aspects of Western beauty,but molding them to the Korean face.The new Korean look became one distinct, from both the Western face and the traditional East Asian face,reminiscent of Koreaâs colonizers.â, This look is sometimes called K-face by sociologists.Yip, Ainsworth and Hugh note that this beauty standard, is supposed to signal global integration, and cosmopolitanism and that the strategic combining, of European elements with a predominantly Asian look, gives off a worldly appearance.Itâs very similar to Instagram face that we have in the West,in the way that the face combines various features, of you know, multiple races to produce a somewhat ethnically ambiguous look,but K-face is still distinctly Korean, just as Instagram face is still distinctly white.Beyond the features themselves,thereâs also a lot of emphasis on proportions in Korean beauty marketing.
For instance, the one to one to one face ratio, that says you should be equally balanced between your brow,your nose, and your chin,and the leg ratio that says you should have a five to three, to two proportion between your thigh, calf and ankle.(Doctor speaking in foreign language), - The hyper focus on proportions might stem, from East Asian beliefs about first impressions in Korea,itâs a concept called, âInsang,â Ann Shin explains, what Insang is in her short story, âLearning To Walk.â, Koreans say you can tell a personâs disposition, by reading their facial expression at rest.Itâs called Insang.You could say a person has a warm Insang or a nervous Insang,or an Insang that shows theyâve been through a lot of hardship.Thatâs not the one that I want. (laughs), Iâm sure the focus on specific proportions is also great industry marketing.These ratios designate seemingly objective measurements, that you can measure your own body up to, and thus modify accordingly at the clinic, if you donât meet them.
Calf Botox literally exists, to atrophy the muscle in your calf so that you can hit that golden ratio.These objective, wink, objective ratios also allow people, to measure other peopleâs bodies as well.A few years ago, BeBoss TV published a YouTube video called,â9 Female Idols with Most Insane Body Proportions in Kpop.â, In their video, they analyze different idol bodies, to determine who has the best body of each group.- [Presenter] According to Celeb Revealed,sheâs 48 kilograms heavy, 167.5 centimeters tall,and easily stands out with body measurements of 34, 25, 31 inches.- Crazy stuff, if you look in the comments,also, most of them are stating their own opinion, of who has the best body rather than asking, why weâre even talking about this in the first place.There is also plenty of forum posts that feed into this body discourse as well.A Reddit post asking, âWhat do fans exactly mean, when an idol has good proportions?â, Received an answer that mentions a head to body ratio.
known as the âEight stacked heads test.â, AKA the perfect body is eight heads tall.Actually the perfect body is five apples tall but whatever.Hu mentions in her book a concept called, the âTechnological Gaze,â she defines it, as an algorithmically determined set of ideal traits, for our facial and body parts that social platforms feed us, through the content we scroll.It represents a power shift from an external male-judging gaze, to a self-policing narcissistic gaze.The self-policing tech gaze creates demand, for what we should look like and also feeds it,thanks to the attention economy, that drives competition among the biggest tech companies.The technological gaze is present across any country, that has access to social media.Itâs the reason why Instagram face is a thing, and why everyone is getting the same treatments, lip filler,chin lipo, rhinoplasties in America,but who explains that Korea is hyper modern,which emphasizes the technological gaze even more.
After all, itâs the most wired place on earth,has world leading internet speeds, and in 2006 had the highest broadband penetration rate, in the world.Seoul is also the fourth most surveyed city in the world, ranked by a number of CCTV cameras per square mile.As a result, itâs unsurprising thereâs such a heavy emphasis on visual culture.I learned a few years ago that some K-pop idols even get nostril Botox.Itâs because when theyâre performing on stage,camera operators will literally zoom in, on specific idol faces while theyâre singing and dancing,and the quality is like 4K.So you can see every sweat droplet on their skin, and the Botox is supposed to prevent the nostrils, from flaring out in a non photogenic manner during their closeups.I mean, if weâre going to zoom in on nostrils, what canât we zoom in on.Procedures like getting your armpit colorized,shaving the back of your skull to look more rounded, and getting Botox injected into your trapezius muscles.
These are all incredibly specific procedures, and hardly noticeable to anyone else,but the fact that people still get them done just goes, to show how stringent beauty standards have become.(upbeat piano music) (keyboard buttons clacking), You know, itâs actually incredible that Korean beauty, is so powerful on the global stage, because Korea had a pretty late start in the beauty game.During the Joseon period, which was 1392 to 1910,makeup was mostly associated with lower class courtesans.This is because Confucianism was popular, and one Confucian value is to keep the body as natural as possible.It wasnât until 1916 that the first mass manufactured Korean beauty product came, onto the scene, a white face powder called Pakabun.But throughout the 20th century, there were some hiccups to industry growth.Following the Korean War, South Korea was ranked, among the poorest nations in the world.Then in 1997,a major economic crash forced the government, into asking the IMF for an emergency loan of $57 billion.
There was a lot of resentment over this bailout, as citizens worried over the potential loss, of their countryâs economic independence.For example, as a condition to the aid,the IMF forced South Korea to admit foreign banks, and allow the import of Japanese goods that had previously been banned.For context, Japan started its Imperial campaign, in the late 1800s and annexed Korea in 1910.They brutally ruled over the country until the end, of World War II and given all the terror, the military incited on the Korean people, and the fact it was still a living memory for most of the population,yeah, it makes sense why there would be distaste over Japanese products.âThe New York Timesâ interviewed a Korean woman at the time, who lamented, âIâm angry at the American, and Japanese demands.If you really wanna help us,donât make us buy your things, just by our things.â, This sentiment was probably felt by the president at the time, Kim Dae-jung.He was also shocked at how much revenue the US.
and UK made from their media industries, and decided that Korea needed its own pop culture industry.After the IMF crisis, he invested money into a new cultural content office.It became a collective effort in the country, to build up the industry as everyone was eager, to eclipse Japanese pop cultural imports.This soft power agenda strategy is known as Hallyu,and yes, it also included the beauty sector.As an example of the governmentâs purposeful investment in the beauty industry.In the early aughts Seoulâs cosmetic surgery clinics, were actually on the verge of shutdown,since there werenât enough patients.But in 2007,the Korea Tourism Organization established medical tourism, as one of its focus areas for growth.Today, a medical tourism support center greets visitors, at the Incheon International Airport, the entry point, for the hundreds of thousands who visit South Korea, for procedures each year.You can also get a value added tax refund.
if you get a cosmetic procedure that is over 15,000 Korean won or about 11 USD.As a result of this effort, the Korean beauty industry grew exponentially.In 2009, about 60,000 foreigners visited Korea for procedures.By 2019, the number of medical tourists reached nearly half a million.By 2018, Korea boasted the most cosmetic surgeons, and most plastic surgery per capita on earth.In her investigative piece on Koreaâs plastic surgery industry,Patricia Marx visited a clinic in the so-called improvement corridor, of the Gangnam District.She notes that in this area there were between 4, and 500 clinics and hospitals within a square mile.Because of how popular Korea is as a medical tourism destination,there are now cottage industries of medical tour guides.I still remember the first time I witnessed, an influencer publicizing her medical tourism journey.This was back in 2017, so it was pretty shocking and memorable.She actually had a deal with a medical tourism agency called Docfinder Korea.
They essentially acted as a middleman hoping her, to book her appointments, transportation and accommodations,and with everything taken care of, it honestly starts, to seem more like a vacation than a hospital visit.There are plenty of travel vloggers who will go to Seoul, and feature a cosmetic procedure, as just one item on their travel itinerary along, with eating delicious food and exploring the city.- [Tourist] My gosh, this smells so good!- [Guest] OhâŠ- So whatâs the next step for the industry then?To build tourist attractions around the hospitals, obviously,Marx notes that one clinic she visited had its own plastic surgery museum,complete with among other oddments, deformed skulls,postoperative shampoo, and a fun house mirror.Websites like Visit Korea will actually advertise, a combination of medical procedures, and tourist destinations with one itinerary titled âMedical Tour Guide to Muan:Enjoy the City Embracing the Sea and Tidal Flats.â.
The itinerary lists hospitals along with restaurants and natural wonders.So itâs these kinds of luxuries and experiences that help make Korea, a popular destination for medical tourism.But you might be wondering why participate in medical tourism at all?Why go through the lengths of getting procedures over in another country, when there are plenty of specialized doctors in many of our home countries?While a lot of procedures are actually cheaper in Korea, than my home country of America.A Bloomberg article interviewed Julie Miller,a 46-year-old from New Jersey who is flying to South Korea, to get Botox and skin tightening.Rebecca Choong Wilkins reports for Bloomberg,âItâs a trip thatâll take her about a day, and the final bill for those treatments isnât cheap,about 30,whereas the same procedure in LA would be $200.
As for double eyelid surgery, you can get one for $300 in Seoul.The price for the procedure in the US is 10 times higher.Jungmi Jun, a researcher at USC reported, in her 2015 study that major surgeries in Korea are offered, at a price two to eight times lower than in the United States.Some hospitals will also price treatments low, to get patients into their clinics, in hopes that those patients will return for more expensive procedures later on.I also have multiple East Asian friends who just do not trust American doctors,believing that these doctors are uninformed, about East Asian facial features and proportions, and will botch them as a result.And as I said before, the specificity of the procedures, that you didnât even know you needed help, to reinforce Koreaâs reputation, as a technologically advanced country that will take care, of you, unless they donât.Like any country with a beauty industry, human error,predatory marketing and clinics focused.
on bottom line profits will lead to botch results or even death.Thereâs also a number of factors specific to medical tourism, that can pose additional problems such as the lack, of translators and presence of illegal brokers.Personally, I find that the best recommendations, for anything from medical doctors to restaurants, to hiking trails,they all come from people I actually know,people who I trust to have gotten this firsthand experience.When youâre a foreigner, unless you have friends, or family based in that country that can tell you whatâs up,for the most part,youâre going to have to rely on the internet, to get your recommendations, and as the saying goes,donât believe everything you read on the internet.Predatory people across Reddit, and other online forums will post fake reviews all the time,even though this is illegal,some posters receive commissions from bringing in clients,which is why they do it.Doctors will also pay commissions to brokers who help foreign patients match.
with their clinics.I should add, this is illegal for domestic patients.Korean law also prohibits the use of influencers for testimonial marketing,but influencers are often still part of a clinicâs marketing scheme.âAl Jazeeraâ reviewed a contract that required a foreign influencer, to produce multiple promotional videos, and social media content about a plastic surgery clinic, in exchange for free surgery,with the clinic dictating specific positive language to be used in posts.The clinic requires that that influencer produce the content, before knowing the final result of the surgery,stipulated that it would review all content, before its release and included confidentiality terms, that effectively prevented disclosure of the sponsored nature of the surgery.When the influencer didnât wanna use the positive language, because she wasnât happy with the results,the company demanded she pay back for the surgery and travel costs.Fortunately, her lawyer got the demand to stop.
after reminding the hospital that they were already doing something illegal, under medical advertising laws.But not every influencer can afford a good lawyer, to argue these clauses or even know that arguing is a possibility.The actual experience of getting the surgery, can also be overwhelming and confusing.One American named Alex, who traveled to South Korea, for a rhinoplasty said she was rushed into surgery, despite having reservations and not being able, to speak with an in-house translator.After the surgery, she experienced complications, including disfigurement due to the implant, protruding through her skin, which forced her, to get an emergency removal surgery in the US,which Iâm sure was an extra wad of cash.She told Al Jazeera, âI felt abandoned, like I was on a conveyor belt.Once they had done the surgery, they didnât wanna deal with me anymore.They kept saying I was still healing when I knew something was seriously wrong.â, Frustrated by inadequate aftercare and unable to secure a refund,
Alex wrote a review with photos on the Gangnam UNNI app,a popular plastic surgery review platform marketed as UNNI, outside South Korea, eager to avoid negative publicity,the hospital offered a full refund,but only after she agreed to delete the review, and sign a confidentiality agreement.The document which was reviewed, by Al Jazeera prohibited her from discussing the contents, of the agreement and her experience on any platform, with failure to comply resulting in financial penalties.Malpractice is everywhere.You know, thereâs an entire reality TV show dedicated, to fixing bad plastic surgery in the US.Some procedures are also just more difficult to do than others.Theyâre more high risk.BBLs have a notoriously high mortality rate compared, to other surgical procedures.Iâm not too familiar with the American legal system,which Iâm sure is tricky to deal with even for citizens.But if you get a procedure abroad, itâs even more difficult, to navigate because youâre not a citizen,
so you have different rights, and Iâm assuming you donât speak the local language,so youâll need translators, youâll need to somehow find a lawyer, et cetera.Additionally, itâs hard to get restitution, if an accident does occur because Korea has strict defamation laws, that make it very difficult for anyone to sue.Thereâs also the issue with ghost doctors, AKA doctors, who perform a surgery that another surgeon was hired for.They come into the operating room when the patient is under general anesthetic.Itâs technically illegal,but regulations are not heavily enforced because itâs hard to prove.Many clinics donât have CCTV cameras, in their operating rooms and you know patients are knocked out.The reason the ghost doctor industry exists is, because of how high demand these clinics are,but rather than just accepting fewer clients,they hire ghost doctors, usually younger,less experienced doctors to maximize profits.Jo Elfving-Hwang, an associate professor.
of Korean studies at the University of Western Australia,told CNN that high profile surgeons often use K-pop stars, or celebrities to promote their clinic,but during busy periods, some just canât deal with the volume of patients,especially as star doctors also need to be available, for consultations with new customers.Ghost doctors operate illegally in America too,but laws in Korea are pretty relaxed even when malpractice is proven.For example, one doctor who asked a nurse to perform eyelid, or nose plastic surgeries at least 90 times,received only a three month suspension.Between 2008 and 2014,the Korean Society of Plastic Surgeons estimated, that there were about 100,000 victims of ghost surgery in South Korea.I should clarify that just, because youâre treated by a ghost doctor doesnât mean, anything bad will happen to you,but it is concerning to not know whatâs happening and also it is illegal.So yeah, just not good.Overall, you know, Iâm not saying that Koreaâs a bad place to get work done.
Obviously many people go without any issues,but I think everyone at the very least should be informed, no matter what country they go to,no matter what specific clinic they go to.Korea has this really good reputation,but that doesnât mean that you shouldnât do any research.There was a girl on TikTok that went viral recently,but she deleted her video maybe, because she was avoiding getting sued for defamation,but she was permanently blinded, by her doctor in Korea when getting filler injected.People just have so much trust in these institutions,but you only have one body, so just be as informed, as you possibly can if you must get a procedure.(upbeat piano music) (keyboard buttons clacking) Despite the risks,cosmetic surgery has become a pretty normalized both in Korea and in LA.A 2020 âGallupâ poll found that since the early 2000s,70% of Koreans donât view cosmetic surgery as taboo.One in three women surveyed all between the ages of 19, and 39 had undergone cosmetic surgery.
59% of men said they would get plastic surgery, to improve their chances on the job market,a number that shot up 30% since 1994.Korean American journalist Jane Chung wrote, for Business Insider that when she was 14,her family offered her double eyelid surgery as a middle school graduation gift.Chung refused because at the time she believed, that permanent body modification was, quote,âA tool of patriarchy to control and subdue women.â Sheâs not wrong.Chung is not the only one whoâs been offered plastic surgery, as a graduation gift, though,itâs common enough in South Korea that dermatology, and plastic surgery apps offer up to 50 to 70% off discounts, to recent high school grads in a three pack, of popular procedures, eyelid surgery, nose jobs,and Botox for jaw contouring.Patricia Marx interviewed a Korean college student who said, âWhen youâre 19,all the girls get plastic surgery.So if you donât do it after a few years, your friends will all look better,but you will look like your unimproved you.â.
Thereâs a statistic that one in four Korean mothers, with daughters between the ages of 12, and 16 have suggested plastic surgery to them.An anonymous Korean woman told âVice,â, that the pressure comes from wanting their kids, to be socially accepted.She says, âEveryone is getting prettier and prettier, and some parents donât want their child to be the ugly one.Itâs like in the 90s if you got a Discman, because your parents didnât want you to be the only kid at school without one.â, This weirdly reminds me of the whole Japanese bento box phenomenon.Walk with me here, in Japan itâs common for mothers, to invest a lot of energy into preparing aesthetically pleasing bento boxes, or lunch boxes for their children.It can take hours to prepare all the ingredients,source the right tools and shape all the foods.Rudiko Tamira, a 43-year-old Japanese woman, with two young children told National Geographic, that she knows mothers who get up at like four oâclock.
or five oâclock in the morning cutting seaweed with scissors.Mariko Oi wrote for BBC about this, and explained that the reason why they do this, is because âThere is an underlying guilt, that we, many Japanese working mothers feel.It was our choice not to give up our careers, so our children shouldnât suffer because of it.â, She also notes that this is an expectation put on mothers, by their communities as well.One woman confessed to her,âThe pressure that my bento must be judged, by the teachers makes it even more stressful.â, Makiko Itoh, author of âThe Just Bento Cookbook,â says, that Bento is a reflection of parenthood.âA lot of it is caused by the fact that many parents want, to get their kids into a good kindergarten, and for that they have to pass the test.So the better the parents perform in their parental duties,including making the right lunches,the more likely their children will be accepted, by good schools and receive a better education.â, A 36-year-old Japanese woman named Kyoko Sudo.
also told Nat Geo her personal experience, of being bullied over bento when she was in school,she recounted, âKids started complaining about what my mother made,âmaybe Kiyokoâs family is very poor, because she only has one egg and one sausage.â, They judged me and my family, you know.â, So in a similar fashion I think that a lot, of the parents encouraging their kids, to get plastic surgery are coming from a good place.You know, they want their kids to fit in, to not be bullied,to get good jobs later in life, and they donât wanna be judged as being bad parents, et cetera.But ultimately it is another pressure point that reinforces structural lookism.Lookism is social prejudice against those who fail, to meet a certain appearance standard, and the word stems from the fat acceptance movement.Lookism is prohibited by a 1995 Korean law,but Helen Chu, a Korean beauty entrepreneur explains, that often the first thing anyone says when they meet you, is related to looks.And as I said, itâs structural.
A 2017 South Korean poll found that nearly 40%, of respondents experienced discrimination, based on their appearances when applying for jobs,up until 2019 when the practice became illegal,it was common for job applications to require headshots from their candidates.Job listings will also use terms like neat, and beautiful to describe ideal candidates.One advertisement that drew media attention specified C, as the ideal bra cup size.Even the Ministry of Employment and Labor once shared a link, on Twitter encouraging job seekers to mind their looks.Suggesting cosmetic surgery has become one, of the seven credentials needed for employment, and asking what type of face companies preferred for its applicants.The post has since been removed.So itâs not a purely superficial interest to get work done.There are actual consequences for being ugly, and honestly, I think if I was in a situation, where I literally could not get a job because of the way I looked,I would consider plastic surgery way more seriously.
Obviously, Iâm not in support, of the cosmetic surgery industry, because at the end of the day this perceived independence, and being able to change your appearance, still reinforces a neoliberal mindset that each of us needs, to self-improve in order to compete in the market.Also, worrying about aesthetic labor distracts us, from focusing on actual structural inequality.So I donât agree with it,but Iâm just saying thereâs reasons, and stepping outside of a system is more difficult, than just paying $300 for double eyelid surgery.Also, every country has this kind of oppressive beauty ideal,but I think the major difference between say Korea, and America is that Korea is more upfront about it.In America to a certain extent,we still cloak plastic surgery discourse, around feeling your best, self-improvement language, doesnât blatantly acknowledge the desire to be pretty, for the approval of society.Thereâs also still shame about getting beauty procedures.Not going to name any names,
but there are many celebrities who will deny getting any work done,even when anyone with eyes can tell they did.Michael Hurt, a sociologist who is half Korean, and half black explains, âThe US still does this,âNo, Photoshop is bad. Be yourself.Donât fall into the trap.â But you canât escape this shit.Korean society says, âFuck it,you look better, so go do that.â, If I can make my meat face look like, the better hyper-Photoshopped digital version of my face,why wouldnât I do that?Itâs not the future, itâs right here in Korea today.Koreans get beat up for looking fake,theyâre body shamed, but basically Korea is doing, what everybody will be doing very soon.â, Yeah, I honestly feel like the reason plastic surgery, isnât more accepted in the US, is because itâs less accessible here, and you know, we have a shrinking middle class, that can barely afford things versus in Korea itâs way more accessible, and so you donât have to be like upper class Hollywood, to be able to afford a nose job,
but not everyone is buying into the beauty industry.Thereâs a movement in Korea called Escape the Corset, that pushes back against beauty standards, with the more radical members foregoing makeup entirely, and shaving their heads.Hu explains why this is so brave, specifically in South Korea,âThe rejection of basic appearance norms comes, with punishing social sanctions for Korean women.These activists have become outcasts at school and at work.Sometimes theyâre even uninvited to their own family gatherings.â, One movement member, Ho Jian explains her experience.âInstead of calling me by my name,my coworkers just call me, âBoy,â âwhy are you like that?â, Theyâll ask me and my family tells me they think appearing, with short hair and being makeup free is unsafe for me.Everyone comments about their own discomfort.At first, I try to explain my thoughts and values,but thatâs not what they wanted to hear,so now Iâm just ignored.â Despite detractors, The Escape The Corset movement.
has successfully ignited many conversations, about womenâs rights and some consumption data actually shows decline, in beauty related spending among Korean women in their 20s.I canât say for sure what caused this, but itâs interesting nonetheless.Numbers from the Ministry of Economy and Finance indicate that between 2015, and 2018, sales of cosmetics, hair products, and other beauty related goods dropped, 53.5 billion Korean won, approximately $44.8 million, among women in their 20s,and this was also the time when Escape the Corset was heavily talked about.Feminist online communities like WOMAD, also have organized in-person demonstrations, and protests such as the B-Wave protests, for abortion rights, which started in 2016, and continued until 2019 when the abortion ban was lifted, in a constitutional court ruling.(upbeat piano music) (keyboard buttons clacking), I think a lot of people who donât know too much about Korea, and are only exposed to K-pop and the industry abuses going on there,
I think they perceive Korea as being a looks obsessed country,but thereâs different motivations for why someone might be obsessed with looks, that go beyond just individual vanity, and itâs after reading these resources,especially Elise Huâs âFlawlessâ that you know,I canât stop promoting because itâs so good.But after reading these things that I feel like Iâm able, to understand or more understand,understand more the nuances behind the beauty industry, and why itâs difficult to make broad stroke statements like, we should just not wear makeup and not get plastic surgery.I mentioned systemic issues before, but another example,Jessica Elfving-Hwang interviewed 20 women living in Seoul, who were 63 and over about their attitudes towards beauty,and the participants explained, that beauty work in Korea at least among elderly women,was understood in the context of respect to others.This concept was referred to as Yewi or correct social etiquette.When Hu interviewed elderly Korean American women.
in Orange County, their attitudes were similar, and that they still believed in performing beauty work, in some way.One woman, Elizabeth exclaimed through laughter,âLet myself go? No, of course not!I still care.I put some moisturizer and a little liner, to look like Iâm awake.â A 71-year-old woman, Joe Young Lim drew a link, between letting herself go and being unhealthy.âIf weâre laying in a hospital, then weâre, you know,burdening our children.â These attitudes are reminiscent, of what journalist Autumn Whitefield-Madrano wrote, as a defense on beauty in 2016.âThe number one thing I hear from women when I ask, about their reasons for performing beauty work, is not that they wanna change how they look,but that they want to look like their best selves.It may be human to dream of transformation,but it is practical to dream of simply looking all the time the way we do, when weâre rested, fed, watered, well sexed, and nicely groomed.In other words, the reason we perform beauty work is.
because we are engaged in chronic hope.â, I think about my own grandma who is retired, married,and mostly only sees people sheâs known for years,AKA people who absolutely do not care what she looks like, yet she styles her hair, keeps her nails painted, and does an elaborate makeup routine every morning.I think about myself and how I feel a lot worse, if I donât change outta my pajamas all day,even if I, you know, donât intend to leave my house.A lot of these attitudes have to do with social conditioning,like we maybe wrongfully associate putting on makeup, with being active or taking part in community,but Hu writes,âWe should ask ourselves if the labor weâre undertaking, is ego driven or soul driven?Does it lead to more connection with ourselves and others or disconnection?â, I think itâs always valuable to know the reasons, for why we go through aesthetic labor, because it can help us come up with alternative methods, for living a freer life.For example, if you know you associate putting on makeup.
with seeing your friends, experiment with what it means, to not wear makeup and still see your friends, and figure out whether or not you can at some point disconnect the two, and then notice whether or not that disconnection brings any more meaning, to your life.I donât know, itâs just food for thought.I think that obviously when you put in plastic surgery, in here, it adds like another wrench, to the equation than just like not wearing makeup, for the day but we like to talk in absolutes when it comes, to beauty discourse.I think it serves a less to think of it in those kinds of dichotomies,especially when weâre talking about other cultures, and you know, the different kinds, of like structural institutions that exist that make us want, to adjust our bodies in this specific way.Okay, (giggles) anyways, thanks for hanging out with me today.My name is Mina. I hope you have a lovely rest of your day.Please let me know in the comments what youâve thought about, when it comes to like plastic surgery in Korea.
I donât know if this is like very niche,but I feel like itâs not that niche anymore, and yeah, I would love to hear any experiences as always,and Iâll see you next time.Okay, bye. (lips smacking).